The Winners Would Be: Oscar, Hatton, Mayweather, and Margarito.

Originally Posted by p4pking

Originally Posted by The Game

Cotto-Oscar:Silly fight dude.Oscar's too big and at this moment in time,too much.

Zab-Hatton:Zab can't handle pressure of any kind,he cracks,Hatton is a relentless pressure machine.Hatton would stop him and I don't think the Collazo fight has a bearing. Louis is a big strong natural WW who could stand and trade with Hatton and could take the rough stuff,no way Judah could take that.Hatton stops him.

Mosley-Maweather:you mean at 154? I was not overly impressed by Sugar Shane in his last fight,he was not fleet footed,hardly landed any great combos and looked a shadow of himself. It would depend how well Floyd could carry the weight but I'd go for Floyd,UD.

Gatti-Margarito.Gatti would stand there and get beaten like a government mule!! Total mismatch.

Nice list though!

I agree completely with all those except for the Judah Hatton fight, I really don't think your right on that one... Zab can handle pressure, he has in the past against fighters like Mickey Ward and Spinks, PBF pressured him a ton, I know he is a bit chinny, but Im saying Hatton has just as much of a chance as getting hurt as he does at welter, but moreso because Judah is faster by a wide margin.. Also, I think you are overrating Collazo just because he beat Hatton... He's not some big strong welter who took all of Hatton's shots and everything else, imo Hatton's shot's weren't as effective at welter, that and Collazo was able to and did tie him up all the time, if anything he fought poorly because he didn't let his hands go enough earlier. Nothing really changed about Hatton, and he is supposed to get strong as the fight goes and have a tremendous workrate... Well why is it that Collazo was able to beat him up so badly in the 12th round then Because he realized he could.. Hatton didn't land a ton of great punches on Collazo, in fact Luis got the FAR better shots off. I think Judah, if he did train seriously and watched tapes of that fight, would be able to beat Hatton, he's a faster southpaw who easily hit's as hard and does have better defense than Collazo, I would give Hatton a punchers chance in that fight.

Agreed, Game, I too think Judah would beat Hatton, and hurt him, possibly stopping him.

P4PKIng,you make valid points but I don't think we saw the best of Ricky,I mean he only had 7 weeks to prepare for the fight and I think he will become more effective the more he fights at that weight and let us not forget,he took Kostya's shots.I alos believe that there is alot of difference between the power of som,eone who was@140 for a long time and a natural WW(as can be seen in that Collazo had Hatto OUT,KT didn't really hurt Hatton at all!). Also,the pressure Spinks and Ward bring is nothing compared to Hatton's,I can't see Zab taking all the punches,and the rough stuff which Hatton would use.At least we partially agree

With Tzyu, Hatton never ate a clean right hand though. Tzyu never got to plant his feet and nail Hatton like he wanted to, so he never actually took Tzyu's power IMO, he smothered it. With Zab, that would not happen. Zab can move a lot better than Kostya and is a lot faster.

True Hulk but I don't think Zab is good enough to dance around Hatton,at least not often.Yeah he's fast,but his KO power@147 is highly over rated and I just don't believe that he can hurt Hatton.I'm guessing you guys(Hulk and P4PKING)are not big Hatton fans?

Originally Posted by BoxingGorilla

Judah - Hatton


This is the best of them. Who would win? I see Judah winning this fight. I'm not sure if he would KO Hatton, but I'm sure Hatton would look like 40 miles of bad road at fights end.

Hahaha - he looks like that before the fight anyway

out of those the one id rather see is mosley vs mayweather

Originally Posted by B@rr3r@

Simple post, with matches no-ones mentioned...

5 fights, and all you need to do is "Quote" me and leave your winners, unless you want to put an explanation!

Oscar De La Hoya v Miguel Cotto

Zab Judah v Ricky Hatton

Shane Moseley v Flloyd Mayweather

Arturo Gatti v Antonio Margarito

I see only four fights

Originally Posted by B@rr3r@

Simple post, with matches no-ones mentioned...

5 fights, and all you need to do is "Quote" me and leave your winners, unless you want to put an explanation!

Oscar De La Hoya v Miguel Cotto

Zab Judah v Ricky Hatton

Shane Moseley v Flloyd Mayweather

Arturo Gatti v Antonio Margarito

i would not mind seeing any of those fights. i would also like to see Cotto vs Castillo , JMM vs MAB , Arce vs Darchinyan and Juan Diaz vs Freitas or Raheem on the same night if possible.

Originally Posted by LuciferTheGreat

Originally Posted by B@rr3r@

Simple post, with matches no-ones mentioned...

5 fights, and all you need to do is "Quote" me and leave your winners, unless you want to put an explanation!

Oscar De La Hoya v Miguel Cotto

Zab Judah v Ricky Hatton

Shane Moseley v Flloyd Mayweather

Arturo Gatti v Antonio Margarito

I see only four fights

Thats what I thought

I agree with hitman fan . The best fight out of them 4 is Mosley vs Mayweather . Id like Shane to win but I get the feeling Floyd would steal a points decision cuz Shane is past his best

Originally Posted by B@rr3r@

Simple post, with matches no-ones mentioned...

5 fights, and all you need to do is "Quote" me and leave your winners, unless you want to put an explanation!

Oscar De La Hoya v Miguel Cotto

Zab Judah v Ricky Hatton

Shane Moseley v Flloyd Mayweather

Arturo Gatti v Antonio Margarito

ODLH vs Cotto - We all know Cotto hasn't been hit by a puncher since Torres. ODLH will hit him. And knock him the fuck out. ODLH TKO 7.

Zab Judah vs Ricky Hatton - This is a fight that actually should happen. This would be a great matchup and the winner would get PBF. Judah's got good KO power when he winds up at 147 and Hatton would give him a target to hit and as much as I wanna choose Zab, we all saw how PBF's body work had Zab grimacing in pain, well Hatton will destroy Zab's lower body to the point of Zab not coming out in the 10th. Hatton TKO 10.

Shane Mosley vs Pretty Boy Floyd - This is fight I only want to see if Margarito or Winky can't be. I think Mosley can bang with any of the 147ers and can KO some of them. But Mosley relies too much on flurries and he doesn't the speed and quickness that made him a star anymore but he will still be a force at 147. If Floyd boxes then it's a UD 12 for PBF, if Floyd decides to trade with Shane, I really could see Shane KOing PBF. With that said I'll say PBF UD 12 because the first shot that hurts PBF, we all know he will change his gameplan. That's why he's #1 P4P.

Arturo Gatti vs Tony Margarito - This would be an absolute war with a ton of landed power punches. This fight would come down to who could take the most punishment. Tony doesn't use his size and keep guys away with the jab, Gatti will land a ton of hard shots on Tony. Don't let his performance against PBF fool you, Gatti looked horrible because Gatti couldn't land. Gatti will land on Tony all night. Outside of Ward, Gatti really only has lost to people that have outboxed him and were better technical boxers and used their skill to make him look foolish. Tony is a big slow guy that Gatti will bang on all night. Gatti TKO 11.

Originally Posted by Lyle

what about Raheem-Corrales?

After the Freitas fight it might be a while before Raheem gets a shot at the spotlite though....He has a Shitload of potential and had the opportunity to shine and get some SERIOUS momentum after the Morales fight but the lackluster performance against Freitas left something to be desired,I thought he had a goodchance in that fight but couldnt come through...

Originally Posted by The Game

True Hulk but I don't think Zab is good enough to dance around Hatton,at least not often.Yeah he's fast,but his KO power@147 is highly over rated and I just don't believe that he can hurt Hatton.I'm guessing you guys(Hulk and P4PKING)are not big Hatton fans?

Nope, can't stand the dirty little troll.

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by The Game

True Hulk but I don't think Zab is good enough to dance around Hatton,at least not often.Yeah he's fast,but his KO power@147 is highly over rated and I just don't believe that he can hurt Hatton.I'm guessing you guys(Hulk and P4PKING)are not big Hatton fans?

Nope, can't stand the dirty little troll.

You cant stand Calzaghe either?? I see a pattern emerging, why is that?

IMO the only fight that could be close here is Judah vs. Hatton and I think he is too fast, and hits too hard for Hatton to stand a chance... If Judah comes in focused like he did vs. Mayweather.. if not Hatton wins a boring fight... except for the Judah chicken dance.