Of course he should...He has always been a respectible champion in and out of the ring and always conducted himself like a gentelman...Gatti has had fight of the year honors and showed us what true heart is about..There is nothing this guy has ever done to shame himself or the game...Even if he has lost his biggest fights he is a credit to the game....Just for you non supporters out there who talk about Gatti losing his biggest fights if the HOF has a spot for Non Champions the a two time belt holder with Gattis background is a shoe in.....