Is Gatti a worthy candidate for the Hall of Fame? - Page 2

**Saddo** · #16 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 02:44 AM

I cant be bothered to read all that

so i say yeah why not his exciting fights deserve a place... after all this aint just about the sweet science its about entertaning the fans and for that he is the king

Wacko3205 · #17 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 02:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaxxKahn

Of course he should...He has always been a respectible champion in and out of the ring and always conducted himself like a gentelman...Gatti has had fight of the year honors and showed us what true heart is about..There is nothing this guy has ever done to shame himself or the game...Even if he has lost his biggest fights he is a credit to the game....Just for you non supporters out there who talk about Gatti losing his biggest fights if the HOF has a spot for Non Champions the a two time belt holder with Gattis background is a shoe in.....

No disrespect...but compared to whom? Honestly...heart just doesn't cut it for me. There are plenty gentleman fighters out there...but they gotta be winners too. I know that Gatti's held a title or two...but no noteworthy wins & when he got beaten...he got beaten down.

Admittedly...I aint a fan of Gatti...but his losses are what makes him "the human highlight reel".

HBO sure do have some cute analogies don't they?

bigragu · #18 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 05:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TaxanBaller

Nope No way. His courage was great. But that does not deserve to be in the hall of fame. He lost all of his big fights

Boxing is about ability and results.....Heart is an additional part.....Gatti never won the "BIG ONE"...for the record I love Gatti as a fighter.....but I also love "BOOM BOOM" Mancini as well....

killersheep · #19 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 05:22 AM

I don't think Gatti quite earned being in the HOF, however he will always be remembered. Gatti-Ward 1-3 were all the stuff of legend, but if just had defense, man with that heart he would have been all that and more.

Violent Demise · #20 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 06:19 AM

Exciting fighter. But he's not a hall of famer.

**CutMeMick** · #21 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 06:45 AM

The IBHOF has IMO been extra nice in some inductees, I think Gatti wont get in but who knows Barry McGuigan is in there already

The Whirlwind · #22 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 09:43 AM

I hear you Daxx, but if the criteria is strictly on quality across the board there is no way in for gatti.

Maybe the Boxing hall of Fame needs to introduce a second tier so they can allow guys like gatti the credit they deserve. The guy still won titles after all.
A second tier for fighters who gave a lot to the game but didn't reach the giddy heights of the truly GREAT fighters.
Leaving the top tier to the chosen few who show surpassing excellence.

Purist · #23 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 09:50 AM

If all you have to do is be exciting to get into the Hall of Fame then we may as well throw Margarito in now

El Gamo · #24 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Starr

If all you have to do is be exciting to get into the Hall of Fame then we may as well throw Margarito in now

Dam right

ICB · #25 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frozensolid_702

Quote:

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Quote:

Originally Posted by frozensolid_702

if evander holyfield gets in, then so should gatti

but for the record, i answered no

yes but holyfield was argueably the greatest cruiserweight of all time and he beat mike tyson beat riddick bowe and beat douglas who had just beaten tyson and was hw champion like 4 times wasnt he ??

youre right about the cruiserweight holyfield

but he beat a waay washed up tyson (think ali vs berbick)

one out of 3 vs. bowe (a far superior hw)

was 1-1-1 against john ruiz

was 1-1 against michael moorer

lost to chris byrd

however, if he does go on to win a hw championship again, (he won't) then he absolutely deserves to be in the hof

tell me if this is hall of fame material............... http://boxrec.com/boxer_display.php?boxer_id=499

the only reason he was hw champ 4 times is because he wasnt successful defending his belt

beat washed up tyson ?? hold on wasnt tyson the one beating everyone in 3 rounds or less and was hw champ at that time and was young yet holyfield lost to bowe and looked shot in that fight and holy was like 40-1 on betting odds or something silly like that so i wouldnt call that a washed up tyson he did excellent against bowe the man was 2 stone heavier 1-1-1 against ruiz is when holy was about 40 and finished same with byrd he lost to moorer but i thought he had problem with hes heart in 1 st fight and pulled shoudler during fight in rematch he beat moorer in 8 rounds

cockey cockney · #26 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wacko3205

This is a loaded question with loads of answers...but the one that I stick to is FWOCK NO!!!

Gatti's brought a lot of excitement...especially amongst his fans...but as a whole...Gatti's done nothing but lose to the best...that shouldn't make him a HOF'er...not in my book.

That's not what it was like back in the day...not from what I remember.

Wacko, spot on!

Sorry Frozensolid i gotta disagree with ya.....Holyfield is 110% a HOF fighter, no doubt about it.

means2184 · #27 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 10:56 PM

WACKO?!? its not the "hall of winning superfights" ...its purely that excitement to fans and heart and list of names on his record you speak of that will ENSURE that hes in the hall of fame ...

but to answer you directly ..ofcourse he does ....he is one of the most popular and "FAMEous' fighters today and has a huge following ....what would keep him out of the hall of fame?? hes EXTREMELY famous and a very exciting fighter

"Is Gatti a worthy candidate for the Hall of Fame?" <--is really a silly question

p4pking · #28 (**permalink**) 09-16-2006, 11:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by means2184

WACKO?!? its not the "hall of winning superfights" ...its purely that excitement to fans and heart and list of names on his record you speak of that will ENSURE that hes in the hall of fame ...

but to answer you directly ..ofcourse he does ....he is one of the most popular and "FAMEous' fighters today and has a huge following ....what would keep him out of the hall of fame?? hes EXTREMELY famous and a very exciting fighter

"Is Gatti a worthy candidate for the Hall of Fame?" <--is really a silly question

I know where your coming from, but I actually agree with Wacko... What would keep Gatti out of the hall of fame? well.. The fact that he couldn't have dreamed of beating anyone who he'll be sharing the spot with, imo.

luvfightgame · #29 (**permalink**) 09-17-2006, 12:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Quote:

Originally Posted by DaxxKahn

Of course he should...He has always been a respectible champion in and out of the ring and always conducted himself like a gentelman...Gatti has had fight of the year honors and showed us what true heart is about..There is nothing this guy has ever done to shame himself or the game...Even if he has lost his biggest fights he is a credit to the game....Just for you non supporters out there who talk about Gatti losing his biggest fights if the HOF has a spot for Non Champions the a two time belt holder with Gattis background is a shoe in.....

No disrespect...but compared to whom? Honestly...heart just doesn't cut it for me. There are plenty gentleman fighters out there...but they gotta be winners too. I know that Gatti's held a title or two...but no noteworthy wins & when he got beaten...he got beaten down.

Admittedly...I aint a fan of Gatti...but his losses are what makes him "the human highlight reel".

HBO sure do have some cute analogies don't they?

Should we take the opinion of a drunk? Just how much can you remember anyway

Just kidding.

means2184 · #30 (**permalink**) 09-17-2006, 03:00 AM

simply ....Gatti is VERY FAMOUS and earned that FAME by what he did inside the ring