Thread: Hypothetical Welterweight fights

Who wins and how?

1) Zab Judah vs. Sharmba Mitchell (Battle of the glass jaws)

2) Paul Williams vs. Carlos Quintana (Battle for the future of the WW division)

3) Miguel Cotto vs. Ricky Hatton (Hard hits bout)

4) Kermit Cintron vs. Vivian Harris (The 'where are they now' fight)

CC god post , imgonna have to go judah , williams , hatton and harris not to sure how though

Judah UD
Williams TKO
Cotto at 147
Harris UD

First one Judah wins by ud or tko

Williams, quintana is a pickem fight for me, I say Quinta has better boxing skills and takes a close sd

Cotto , Hatton, could be fight of the year! I say cotto wins by ud in a war.

Cintron, Harris this fight would have some good moments for both fighters but Harris is experience pulls him through this one, I say he wins by late stoppage.

Judah takes out Sharmba pretty easily, TKO before 8.

Quintana wouldn't be able to miss Williams wide open chin all night, UD or a late stoppage.

Cotto UD-Don't know why, used to say Hatton, but I think Cotto's improving while Hatton's regressing. Not a confident pick, especially cause Cotto hasn't even fought at 147 yet.

Cintron-Harris: Somebody gets knocked out. P4P Harris is probably better even though he's overrated, but I'd probably go with Cintron cause although Harris is slicker I don't think he's that slick, not enough to deal with a much bigger, and more powerful guy in Cintron. Not a confident pick either cause they're both mentally fragile.

Niccceee thread..

Judah for sure,too fast for Mitchell and may hurt him or win on points.

Quintana,Williams is way way to open for someone as slick and as smart as Quintana. Quintana would counter him al night long although Williams would have his moments.

Cotto at 147,even though I have yet to see him there and it would be closer at 140,I#d still say Cotto. He can fight backfoot,frontfoot and has the power to keep Hatton off and from what I have seen,Hatton cannot fight going backwards,he only knows one way and Cotto would be just banging away!

Cintron,has alot of power,and is overlooked jus because Margarito dismantled him. His fight with Suarez should be a war!

Originally Posted by El Gamo

Niccceee thread..

Judah for sure,too fast for Mitchell and may hurt him or win on points.

Quintana,Williams is way way to open for someone as slick and as smart as Quintana. Quintana would counter him al night long although Williams would have his moments.

Cotto at 147,even though I have yet to see him there and it would be closer at 140,I#d still say Cotto. He can fight backfoot,frontfoot and has the power to keep Hatton off and from what I have seen,Hatton cannot fight going backwards,he only knows one way and Cotto would be just banging away!

Cintron,has alot of power,and is overlooked jus because Margarito dismantled him. His fight with Suarez should be a war!

Agreed on all points except the last one but they both kinda suck so who cares... I don' see why it isn't fair to overlook Cintron, I mean what can you go by other than his fight with Margarito.. Ok he beat Teddy Reid and Estrada but had big troubles in both and neither of those guys are anything special at this point.

Super Judah by TKO
The Punisher by SD
Thats too close to call for me right now.
Cintron by tko

Originally Posted by killersheep

Who wins and how?


1) Zab Judah vs. Sharmba Mitchell (Battle of the glass jaws)

2) Paul Williams vs. Carlos Quintana (Battle for the future of the WW division)

3) Miguel Cotto vs. Ricky Hatton (Hard hits bout)

4) Kermit Cintron vs. Vivian Harris (The 'where are they now' fight)

1) Sharmba Mitchell got old , I give Zab the edge in this one. Judah 8th round stoppage

2) Williams - 4th R KO

3) Hatton wins a close decision at 140 Cotto wins UN Dec at 147

4) Cintron has momentum going and Harris looked good his last outing. but I go with Harris Un Dec

Originally Posted by Lords Gym

Originally Posted by killersheep

Who wins and how?


1) Zab Judah vs. Sharmba Mitchell (Battle of the glass jaws)

2) Paul Williams vs. Carlos Quintana (Battle for the future of the WW division)

3) Miguel Cotto vs. Ricky Hatton (Hard hits bout)

4) Kermit Cintron vs. Vivian Harris (The 'where are they now' fight)

1) Sharmba Mitchell got old , I give Zab the edge in this one. Judah 8th round stoppage

2) Williams - 4th R KO

3) Hatton wins a close decision at 140 Cotto wins UN Dec at 147

4) Cintron has momentum going and Harris looked good his last outing. but I go with Harris Un Dec

POST of the day! Spot on all around mate, enjoy your

Thanks mate ! CC back at yeah ! appreciate the complement !

Originally Posted by warreng

CC god post , imgonna have to go judah , williams , hatton and harris not to sure how though

I agree with all but the Hatton pick......Hatton has been exposed....

Originally Posted by killersheep

Who wins and how?

1) Zab Judah vs. Sharmba Mitchell (Battle of the glass jaws)

2) Paul Williams vs. Carlos Quintana (Battle for the future of the WW division)

3) Miguel Cotto vs. Ricky Hatton (Hard hits bout)

4) Kermit Cintron vs. Vivian Harris (The 'where are they now' fight)

1) Judah (though I think Judah will loose his next fight)
2) Quintana UD, Williams can punch but I think Quintana can take it, Quintana moves well and would make Williams miss countering well. If Sharmba a natural 140 was able to stun Williams then Quintanas longer reach and more natural 147 power punch would have more effect.
3) This is tough cause we have yet to see what Cottos gonna bring to 147, power? size? what? We already saw that Hatton at 147 just won't be. But Hattons tough and he smothers you and gets all in your face. For some reason I think if he can get away with fighting that type of style he could get a Decision over Cotto. But a well fought fight, none of that ballroom dancing (holding/hugging) that Hatton like to pull off Cotto beats.
4) Draw!!!! I don't know Cintron struggled with Estrada badly and it's not that he struggled it's that he made it be a struggle when he decided to throw wildly and exchange punches like that, he took one too many punches in that fight that he shouldn't have taken. Harris at 147 I don't think thats gonna fit him well. Cintron late stopage.

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

1) Judah (though I think Judah will loose his next fight)

Not if he fights Margarito

Originally Posted by Starr

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

1) Judah (though I think Judah will loose his next fight)

Not if he fights Margarito

If you only knew that Margarito could give a fooook!! about Judah now.
Judah who?
Judah thought that by prancing around with those belts over his shoulders and running his mouth was gonna do the job, well guess what?Wake up call it takes a lot more then that. I personally don't think....and I've said it before Judah does not have what it takes to be on top. His attention span is that of a 4 yr. old. He has everything else and I can accept that, power, ability, everything else you wan't to name but he doesnt have it ALL to stay on top.