Thread: gerald mcclellan vs tommy hearns who wins

Originally Posted by dennis

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

Whats ridiculous is that your comparing the Duran vs Hearns fight in which Tommy is 5 inces taller and physically stronger than Duran to a Hypothetical fight Hearns vs Mcclellan were Gerald is 1 in taller than Hearns and is the Naturally stronger guy...AND YOU SWEAR UP AND DOWN THAT THE 2 FIGHTS WOULD HAVE THE SAME OUTCOME.....

Originally Posted by dennis

styles do make fights. tommy hearns would be my choice and gerald yours. fair enough. At the end of the day it would be a great fight and thats what its all about.


Tommys the winner though. HAHAHA

Ok, explain how. I think Gerald would win, you think Hearns would win. Let's debate it a little. No insults. You go first. Why would Hearns win?

Originally Posted by Majesty

Originally Posted by Gyrokai

Gerald's chin was sturdy, but once it was tested, he lost. Right?

This fight isn't fair anyways, Gerald is too big anyhow.
P4P, Gerald never had the chance to challenge Tommy's Punching Power Status,
because his career was cut short. But before it, his power was unbelievable.
He was just so aggresive.

No, Julian Jackson tested it

Alright.

... I still say this fight isn't fair, heheh. Gerald is just too big. He was a BIG Middy too.

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by dennis

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

Whats ridiculous is that your comparing the Duran vs Hearns fight in which Tommy is 5 inces taller and physically stronger than Duran to a Hypothetical fight Hearns vs Mcclellan were Gerald is 1 in taller than Hearns and is the Naturally stronger guy...AND YOU SWEAR UP AND DOWN THAT THE 2 FIGHTS WOULD HAVE THE SAME OUTCOME.....

who hit harder barkley or gerald i say gerald  and hearns got koed by barkley and barkley was about 6 foot himself so i think gerald could ko hearns aswell

Originally Posted by brazilianbomber

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by dennis

if mcclelan couldnt beat benn he couldnt beat hearns.

That Philosophy and Formula never means anything...Styles make fights...I think Nigel Benn at 160 could probably Take Hearns as well...Nigel was another freak of nature

You should be focused on selling Gap, Carcare, and making two points on the backend

Funny you should say that I just spot delivered a Jeep to a 20 yrl and sent it out with Gap and 2 points....Thats why I'm the champ

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by dennis

like i said. similar to the herans and duran fight. hearns wins KO.

Whats ridiculous is that your comparing the Duran vs Hearns fight in which Tommy is 5 inces taller and physically stronger than Duran to a Hypothetical fight Hearns vs Mcclellan were Gerald is 1 in taller than Hearns and is the Naturally stronger guy...AND YOU SWEAR UP AND DOWN THAT THE 2 FIGHTS WOULD HAVE THE SAME OUTCOME.....

who hit harder barkley or gerald i say gerald and hearns got koed by barkley and barkley was about 6 foot himself so i think gerald could ko hearns aswell

You are correct my friend Gerald was one of the P4P hardest hitters in the history of the sport.....Also Barkley and Hearns are both 6'1

eralier u said... that Hagler could punch but not nearly as hard as Gerald McClellan. Hagler could hit much harder that G man and was introuble in his fight with hearns. i think it would go the same way as the hagler and hearns fight but with G man geting knocked out instead of the hitman.

how can you say mclelan punched harder than hagler.

Originally Posted by dennis

how can you say mclelan punched harder than hagler.

hagler used to chop man down with jolting punches hagler had good power by geralds was freakish power like with john mugabi hagler chopped him down with nice jolting punches

how many gerald mcclelan fights have u actually seen

Originally Posted by dennis

how many gerald mcclelan fights have u actually seen

both of julian jackson fights one with benn and one with john mugabi

if you have only watched 4 fights of mcclelan. how many hearns fights have you seen

Everyone forgets that Hearns had tremendous boxing skills and if he wanted could out box mcllelan.
no one has sergestesd that yet. not all slugfests end in knockouts do they. gatti vs ward. barrera vs morrales, ali vs frazier

dennis, want to debate this?

I think Gerald would win.

Tell me how, and why Hearns would win.

Tommy Hearns had unbelivable punching power just like Gerald and a great chin. Tommy also had much faster hands to deliver quick and powerful shots. Most people forget about tommy having great boxing ability and being able to stay on the outside and wear his opponents down. Gerald usually went in from the first round and tried to land a big shot which he done well. I think tommy would stay on the outside moving around gerald and wear him down. Gerald would then start to slow and tommy would hit him with a big shot around about the 6th round which would knock gerald out.

what do you think would have happened Majesty