Thread: 10 P4P

Post your lists
1) PBF
2) Winky
3)Pacman
4) Taylor
5) Hopkins
6) r. Marquez
7) Calzaghe
jm. Marquez
9) Hatton
10) Barrera

Look good to me.

1. PBF= undefeated and always the smaller guy inside the ring but wins. Most skillfull fighter today IMO.
2. Winky= beats Tito in his prime and beats Mosely twice need I say more. Impecable defense to boot.
3. PAC= like PBF is almostalways the smaller guy but carries the bigger punch.
4. Hopkins= despie his losses with JT which I think the first one he won. His win over the naturally bigger Tarver is a feat for a man of his age. Like PBF great skill.
5. Mosely= his 2 kayo wins over the naturally bigger Vargas won me over again.
6. R. Marquez= great puncher, great boxer and exciting like PAC. Moves up in weight and beats Vazuez places him here.
7. Miguel Cotto= undefeated and probably lb4lb one of the hardest punchers today. Great body punching and overall skill.
8. Joe Calzaghe= longest reinging streak is hard to beat, and beating Lacy shut most of us up.
9. MAB= even losing to JMM, I'm impressed with his overall tenacity bouncing back from defeat over and over.
10. Klit= most skillfull heavweight today, the future and hope of the division.

Sorry it's pretty subjective

subjective is an under statement. you have cotto on the list but not JMM. can't be mad at PBF at the top spot.

Originally Posted by 'The Boxer'

subjective is an under statement. you have cotto on the list but not JMM. can't be mad at PBF at the top spot.

i honestly dislike floyd but his suremacy can't be denied. i also believe cotto will be number 1 next year i use to think cotto was just good at 140 becase of his size but now i think otherwise.

mikeboxing's list is pretty good. I would however have Taylor ahead of Winky though. Beating Hopkins twice counts for something. Mosley was undersized for their fights. Klitchko is definately top 12 but the heavies are oddly uninteresting. There are a slew of very good and accomplished fighters that aren't here. It takes a defining fight to made a p4per.

Originally Posted by a harmful of swallows

mikeboxing's list is pretty good. I would however have Taylor ahead of Winky though. Beating Hopkins twice counts for something. Mosley was undersized for their fights. Klitchko is definately top 12 but the heavies are oddly uninteresting. There are a slew of very good and accomplished fighters that aren't here. It takes a defining fight to made a p4per.

I put Winky ahead cuz imo he beat Taylor, klit could be in the top 20 but not top 12, mosley?, cotto?

Where is Kessler?

He would beat both Calzaghe, Winky and Hop

Originally Posted by Elephant Beer

Where is Kessler?

He would beat both Calzaghe, Winky and Hop

dont agree, calzaghe would out point him, winky is a tough call since hes much smaller, but since he handled taylor , winky wins, hop wins , but kessler perchaps top 15