Thread: If calzaghe beats Kessler and Taylor???

If Calzaghe beats both these guys do you think he can be rated as the best,most accomplished/succussful, SMW there has ever been. I know the great RJJ might have a claim but for the amount of time Calzaghe has now dominated at the weight he must have a case!!!!!!!!

He would get my vote if he can pull off those two wins...

Me personally think Roy Jones best time came at Lightheavy not supermiddle he did'nt do a deal at supermiddle he beat Toney who as we all know was weight drained Jones would have probably beat him anyway he only had a further 5 fights at supermiddle after Toney.

so you agree calzaghe then

Originally Posted by gudnite vienna

If Calzaghe beats both these guys do you think he can be rated as the best,most accomplished/succussful, SMW there has ever been. I know the great RJJ might have a claim but for the amount of time Calzaghe has now dominated at the weight he must have a case!!!!!!!!

He would get my vote if he can pull off those two wins...

Yes but i doubt he will fight either probably be a new Manfredo.

Originally Posted by gudnite vienna

so you agree calzaghe then

Yes he should be higher ranked than Jones in supermiddles of all time the highest i don't know about that im not a fan of his so its hard i preferred Benn and Eubank

calzaghe hasn't beaten anybody except lacy and old eubank...he has the fights right there but won't take them..roy fought whoever the best was esp the fighters in his own country...kessler is right next door he should have been fought him...and a win over taylor wouldn't do much seeing as how taylor is flawed and would be moving up...i think he should make the fight for the winner of hopkins-wright he cann;t let that fight past him before he retires...

I think he has to beat 2 more huge names after kessler and Taylor, for him to be considered great.

I respect Joe tremendously. Always have & always will...a bit frustrated with him of late...but if he works it out...then thumbs up to him.

I'd love to see him defeat Taylor & Tarver...but not Hopkins, Kessler, or Wright.

I'd just rather he didn't fight them at all. Too big a fan of all three names & don't want to see any of them lose.

I want him to fight his mandatory (Inkin) too.