Thread: In Your Opinion What Should Toney's Rec Be?

I would go for 76-2-1 And i havnt seen the one draw of his fairly early in his career so i have to leave that out..

Losses to Rjj and Sam Peter Imo..

Who else?

71 wins 43 kos 6 losses


Win over Peter
Loss to Dave Tiberi



I haven't see McCallum fights and few of the others but Toney had alot of close fights from what i heard he should of lost imo he certainly lost to Tiberi that was a robbery.

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

71 wins 43 kos 6 losses


Win over Peter
Loss to Dave Tiberi



I haven't see McCallum fights and few of the others but Toney had alot of close fights from what i heard he should of lost imo he certainly lost to Tiberi that was a robbery.

You really think so?

Imo toney is vastly misunderstood and people missed out on a lot of his subtleties and defence earlier in his career..

They still do to this day when it comes to it being sloppy as he is a heavier bloke rather then young and people unaware of what to look for ..

Originally Posted by Tito_BHB

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

71 wins 43 kos 6 losses


Win over Peter
Loss to Dave Tiberi



I haven't see McCallum fights and few of the others but Toney had alot of close fights from what i heard he should of lost imo he certainly lost to Tiberi that was a robbery.

You really think so?

Imo toney is vastly misunderstood and people missed out on a lot of his subtleties and defence earlier in his career..

They still do to this day when it comes to it being sloppy as he is a heavier bloke rather then young and people unaware of what to look for ..

Well i know man but all im pointing out is that he should of lost the Tiberi fight and he had alot of close decisions in which he should of lost thats from what i heard i will have to see McCallum fights.

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Originally Posted by Tito_BHB

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

71 wins 43 kos 6 losses


Win over Peter
Loss to Dave Tiberi



I haven't see McCallum fights and few of the others but Toney had alot of close fights from what i heard he should of lost imo he certainly lost to Tiberi that was a robbery.

You really think so?

Imo toney is vastly misunderstood and people missed out on a lot of his subtleties and defence earlier in his career..

They still do to this day when it comes to it being sloppy as he is a heavier bloke rather then young and people unaware of what to look for ..

Well i know man but all im pointing out is that he should of lost the Tiberi fight and he had alot of close decisions in which he should of lost thats from what i heard i will have to see McCallum fights.

Aye ..Your not wrong

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Originally Posted by Tito_BHB

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

71 wins 43 kos 6 losses


Win over Peter
Loss to Dave Tiberi



I haven't see McCallum fights and few of the others but Toney had alot of close fights from what i heard he should of lost imo he certainly lost to Tiberi that was a robbery.

You really think so?

Imo toney is vastly misunderstood and people missed out on a lot of his subtleties and defence earlier in his career..

They still do to this day when it comes to it being sloppy as he is a heavier bloke rather then young and people unaware of what to look for ..

Well i know man but all im pointing out is that he should of lost the Tiberi fight and he had alot of close decisions in which he should of lost thats from what i heard i will have to see McCallum fights.

I haven't seen the Tiberi fight but I understand the W did go to the wrong guy... As for the McCallum fights I think they were scored about right, the first fight was razor thin and a draw was fitting.. Id say Toney edged the next two.. I also feel he lost the first fight to Griffin but definetly won the second. He clearly beat Peter the first time imo.