Thread: Where is Joe C p4p now?

Thoughts peeps?

behind PBF / PACMAN / Hopkins / JMM / somewere around 5 -7

Heres how I have it.

1. PBF
2. PAC
3. JMM
4. JOE
5. Hopkins
6. Vasquez
7. Rafael
8. Hatton
9. Winky
10. Cotto

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Heres how I have it.

1. PBF
2. PAC
3. JMM
4. JOE
5. Hopkins
6. Vasquez
7. Rafael
8. Hatton
9. Winky
10. Cotto

Thats' probably the best list I've seen thus far. Very agreeable. I find it strange when people have Mosley high on their lists. I think I'd take out Cotto and put in Pavlik,Cotto,Calderon and a few others are banging on the door for me.

I think i said in another thread a while ago id place him at 4th in the p4p list..i dont know if theres anyone he could take on to go any higher #

PBF PAC JMM....just have better opposition available to them.

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Heres how I have it.

1. PBF
2. PAC
3. JMM
4. JOE
5. Hopkins
6. Vasquez
7. Rafael
8. Hatton
9. Winky
10. Cotto

Good list Mick, nice to see someone put a list up that doesn't embarrass the site and make us look like Dogshite boxing

My List:

1. 'Pretty Boy' Floyd Maywether Jr.
2. Manny 'Pacman' Pacquiao
3. 'Dinamita' Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Bernard 'The Executioner' Hopkins
5. 'The Pride Of Wales' Joe Calzaghe
6. Israel 'Magnifico' Vazquez
7. Ricky 'The Hitman' Hatton
8. Rafael Marquez
9. Kelly 'The Ghost' Pavlik
10. Ivan 'El Niño De Hierro' Calderon

Originally Posted by Sugar_Shaw

My List:

1. 'Pretty Boy' Floyd Maywether Jr.
2. Manny 'Pacman' Pacquiao
3. 'Dinamita' Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Bernard 'The Executioner' Hopkins
5. 'The Pride Of Wales' Joe Calzaghe
6. Israel 'Magnifico' Vazquez
7. Ricky 'The Hitman' Hatton
8. Rafael Marquez
9. Kelly 'The Ghost' Pavlik
10. Ivan 'El Niño De Hierro' Calderon

Thats interesting to see Kelly in your list...ive deided not to rate him until after the Jermaine taylor rematch..if he beats him the second time i would definatly have to consider him as a top 10 fighter

I only like to rate as top 5 though so my list.

1. Floyd Maywether Jr
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Joe Calzaghe
5. B-hop

i have him third

1. PBF
2. PAC
3. JMM
4. Hopkins
5. JOE
6. Vasquez
7. Rafael
8. Hatton
9. Winky
10. Cotto

I have hopkins ahead of joe because of what he has accomplished in boxing and the people he has fought. The people hopkins fought and beat calzaghi can only dream of. Although calzaghi is a a v v v good champ, hopkins is a great.

I think its out of Joe and Hopkins whos number 1 . Probably Joe cuz Hopkins has lost recently a cxouple times and helost in the middle of his career to Jones and he lost at the start . Joe is unbeaten throughout . Winner of PBF - Hatton at 3 .

1) Mayweather
2) Calzaghe
3) Pacman
3) Hopkins
4) JMM
5) Cotto
6) Hatton
7) Mosley
Kessler
9) Israel Vasquez
10) Winky

How is Kessler in the top 10

IMO Joe is second to Floyd. I wouldn't argue if Pac JMM or B-hop is rated above him, all are very close. I put Joe and Floyd top of the 5 since they have always figured out their opponents. On paper wins though, Pac and Hopkins have better resumees.

I have to agree with the rest of the general population Joe sits at about 5th or so, Floyd still holds the number one spot followed by Pacquiao, JMM, Hopkins then either Vazquez or Hatton, in any order just as long as Floyd is #1, Not that I am a Floyd fan but it is hard to argue that point.

Calzaghe has not had the level of comp these other guys have had...EG- Pacquiao- Barrera, Morales...

He fits in comfortable it the middle