Thread: I Just A Heard Rumor That Andy Lee vs John Duddy Could Be Next

I can't post the link but i just see that this could be very possible, what would be your thoughts on this match up ??

Steward said it by the way.

Andy called out Duddy right after his fight. However, It is the opinion of both the media and public they won't be brought together just yaet as they are making plenty of money independently and they will delay they're meeting until they can maximise the profit to be made.

Duddy has a fight in Feburary already schedualed....Assuming he wins and Pavlik beats Taylor in the rematech Pavlik and Duddy's camp have already entered negotiations for a June showdown between the two

He fights Vanda in February I believe

I'm not as high on Lee as Manny is but he's still better than Duddy IMO even if Duddy has more experience.

I think he'd stop him actually.

Although its a fight I would eventually love to see I just dont think it is a good time for it now.


Both fighters are developing well and it would be a very risky fight for both men. Lee is a real prospect imo and will be a world champ. Duddy will never be world champ becuase he gets hit far too much but he could still damage the young Lee and it could hurt Lee's progression big time to lose to Duddy.

I would like to see Duddy get a shot at a world title some time this year. He will lose imo and then Id like to see him fight Lee, when Lee gets a few more fights under his belt. I think Lee will beat Duddy and he can then go on and have a shot at the world title.


Really think Lee is the real deal though...reminds me of thomas Hearns.

yeh am not sold on Duddy, Probably sold a bit more on Andy Lee

don't think these two will be brought together just yet tho.

Well I'm not high on either one I gotta say I say Duddy take some big hits against Campas and was impressed with how he took them and fought back. (That fight was candidate for FOTY)
In that fight Duddy showed courage and loads of heart.
If they met today I'd take Duddy by decision.
Lee's too green for my likings, skills are there but still too green for my likings.

This fight won't happen right away for 2 reasons.

1. Lee will take a few more fights before he fights someone like Duddy.
2. Duddy isn't going to risk messing up his chance for a big money fight with Pavlik.

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Well I'm not high on either one I gotta say I say Duddy take some big hits against Campas and was impressed with how he took them and fought back. (That fight was candidate for FOTY)
In that fight Duddy showed courage and loads of heart.
If they met today I'd take Duddy by decision.
Lee's too green for my likings, skills are there but still too green for my likings.

Campas was 35 and well past his prime and Duddy got a gift decision against Campas, plus Campas was only ever goodish even in his prime. It was good fight no doubt but i don't think getting controversial decision over shot Campas is that much of an achievement.

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Well I'm not high on either one I gotta say I say Duddy take some big hits against Campas and was impressed with how he took them and fought back. (That fight was candidate for FOTY)
In that fight Duddy showed courage and loads of heart.
If they met today I'd take Duddy by decision.
Lee's too green for my likings, skills are there but still too green for my likings.

Campas was 35 and well past his prime and Duddy got a gift decision against Campas, plus Campas was only ever goodish even in his prime. It was good fight no doubt but i don't think getting controversial decision over shot Campas is that much of an achievement.

You misread my statement.
I was pointing out that he showed heart & courage taking bits from Campas whos still a hard puncher even today. Campas is a gate keeper and up and coming prospects fight him if you get past him then your good to move on to the next level. I didn't say the decision was right however the decision stands and that's what I'm going by. I too think Campas won. Still he was awarded the win and that's that.
Check out how many prospects he's blasted out in the last 2 or 3 years.
Sometimes as fans we put too much emphasis when figthers struggle in certain fights. I brougth this up during the Cintron thread where you were saying cause he struggled in his last fight he would loose to Williams. Going on that performance. ODLH struggled with John John bad early in his career but still ODLH went on to beat other fighters who were much better then John John. Duddy struggled with Campas but learned that he can take some shots and dig down and fight on till the end.

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Well I'm not high on either one I gotta say I say Duddy take some big hits against Campas and was impressed with how he took them and fought back. (That fight was candidate for FOTY)
In that fight Duddy showed courage and loads of heart.
If they met today I'd take Duddy by decision.
Lee's too green for my likings, skills are there but still too green for my likings.

Campas was 35 and well past his prime and Duddy got a gift decision against Campas, plus Campas was only ever goodish even in his prime. It was good fight no doubt but i don't think getting controversial decision over shot Campas is that much of an achievement.

You misread my statement.
I was pointing out that he showed heart & courage taking bits from Campas whos still a hard puncher even today. Campas is a gate keeper and up and coming prospects fight him if you get past him then your good to move on to the next level. I didn't say the decision was right however the decision stands and that's what I'm going by. I too think Campas won. Still he was awarded the win and that's that.
Check out how many prospects he's blasted out in the last 2 or 3 years.
Sometimes as fans we put too much emphasis when figthers struggle in certain fights. I brougth this up during the Cintron thread where you were saying cause he struggled in his last fight he would loose to Williams. Going on that performance. ODLH struggled with John John bad early in his career but still ODLH went on to beat other fighters who were much better then John John. Duddy struggled with Campas but learned that he can take some shots and dig down and fight on till the end.

Campas is a gate keeper and up and coming prospects fight him if you get past him then your good to move on to the next level.

But in my opinion Duddy didn't get past Campas, he got a gift decision plus you have to realize after his fight with Duddy he lost to 19-1 fighter and then struggled against journeyman Norberto Bravo. So that just shows you what kind of level Campas was at in that time in his career.

Sometimes as fans we put too much emphasis when figthers struggle in certain fights. I brougth this up during the Cintron thread where you were saying cause he struggled in his last fight he would loose to Williams.

I never thought Cintron would beat Williams in the first place even before his fight with Jesse Feliciano.

Going on that performance. ODLH struggled with John John bad early in his career but still ODLH went on to beat other fighters who were much better then John John. Duddy struggled with Campas but learned that he can take some shots and dig down and fight on till the end.

Molina was former IBF Superfeatherweight champion and made 8 defense's he also made 3 defense's earlier in his career but lost twice to Tony Lopez. Molina moved up to Lightweight and did give Oscar De La Hoya all he could handle but the difference is, Molina was still in his peak plus he had not lost in almost 5 years. Oscar De La Hoya only had 16 pro fights at the time so he dealt with former world champion who hadn't lost in 5 years pretty good if you ask me. Thats totally different to Duddy struggling with an old shot Campas, plus Oscar De La Hoya had shown even before Molina fight that he had the skills to be elite Duddy never has.

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Campas is a gate keeper and up and coming prospects fight him if you get past him then your good to move on to the next level.

But in my opinion Duddy didn't get past Campas, he got a gift decision plus you have to realize after his fight with Duddy he lost to 19-1 fighter and then struggled against journeyman Norberto Bravo. So that just shows you what kind of level Campas was at in that time in his career.

I guess I'll repeat it again. I think Duddy also lost to Campas BUT the books show he won so that's that. Now I can understand that you don't acknowledge it or see it that way. But it's done with....

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Sometimes as fans we put too much emphasis when figthers struggle in certain fights. I brougth this up during the Cintron thread where you were saying cause he struggled in his last fight he would loose to Williams.

I never thought Cintron would beat Williams in the first place even before his fight with Jesse Feliciano.

Got it, but you did say "After that performance I give Cintron no chance at beating Williams".
I was poitning out that we (me included) put too much emphasis on certain fights when fighters have "live" opponents.

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Going on that performance. ODLH struggled with John John bad early in his career but still ODLH went on to beat other fighters who were much better then John John. Duddy struggled with Campas but learned that he can take some shots and dig down and fight on till the end.

Molina was former IBF Superfeatherweight champion and made 8 defense's he also made 3 defense's earlier in his career but lost twice to Tony Lopez. Molina moved up to Lightweight and did give Oscar De La Hoya all he could handle but the difference is, Molina was still in his peak plus he had not lost in almost 5 years. Oscar De La Hoya only had 16 pro fights at the time so he dealt with former world champion who hadn't lost in 5 years pretty good if you ask me. Thats totally different to Duddy struggling with an old shot Campas, plus Oscar De La Hoya had shown even before Molina fight that he had the skills to be elite Duddy never has.

In no way was I comparing them as fighters. I mean ODLH was a gold medalist and had an outstanding amateur.
I could rephrase myself names, titles & records aside when "prospects" and or "contenders" struggle with an opponent they are quickly singled out by us the fans.
"Well he struggled against a journeyman"
"Well he struggled against a nobody"
Fighters have off nights, sometimes as I said a well prepared opponent who doesn't look like much on paper can give the best fighter around trouble.

Originally Posted by Ricardo "Finito" Lopez

Campas is a gate keeper and up and coming prospects fight him if you get past him then your good to move on to the next level.

But in my opinion Duddy didn't get past Campas, he got a gift decision plus you have to realize after his fight with Duddy he lost to 19-1 fighter and then struggled against journeyman Norberto Bravo. So that just shows you what kind of level Campas was at in that time in his career.

Sometimes as fans we put too much emphasis when figthers struggle in certain fights. I brougth this up during the Cintron thread where you were saying cause he struggled in his last fight he would loose to Williams.

I never thought Cintron would beat Williams in the first place even before his fight with Jesse Feliciano.

Going on that performance. ODLH struggled with John John bad early in his career but still ODLH went on to beat other fighters who were much better then John John. Duddy struggled with Campas but learned that he can take some shots and dig down and fight on till the end.

Molina was former IBF Superfeatherweight champion and made 8 defense's he also made 3 defense's earlier in his career but lost twice to Tony Lopez. Molina moved up to Lightweight and did give Oscar De La Hoya all he could handle but the difference is, Molina was still in his peak plus he had not lost in almost 5 years. Oscar De La Hoya only had 16 pro fights at the time so he dealt with former world champion who hadn't lost in 5 years pretty good if you ask me. Thats totally different to Duddy struggling with an old shot Campas, plus Oscar De La Hoya had shown even before Molina fight that he had the skills to be elite Duddy never has.

Just to add further to some of the points you've made here, I disagree that Duddy got a gift decision. I had Duddy edging it, but I can't see how someone could have the fighters more than a round or two away from each other. It was generous on points, but I felt that the judges did go the right way, although perhaps by a little much. We can argue people who got losses when they deserved to win all night, but as Mick said it's done with.

As for struggling with certain fighters, even the p4p legends will have an off night against an awkward fighter, or come in against a guy where the styles don't gel. I think Cintron took a whole lot more stick about the Feliciano fight than some more popular fighters would take in similar situations.

Fact is Duddy has got past two experienced vets in the past 12 months or so with world level experience, and whilst the ODLH analogy doesn't work, Duddy's record compares favourably with pretty much every middleweight pushing for world status at the moment, and as for a fight with Lee, I think he'd be too much even for Lee's slick style.

Originally Posted by CutMeMick

Well I'm not high on either one I gotta say I say Duddy take some big hits against Campas and was impressed with how he took them and fought back. (That fight was candidate for FOTY)
In that fight Duddy showed courage and loads of heart.
If they met today I'd take Duddy by decision.
Lee's too green for my likings, skills are there but still too green for my likings.

Duddy has since been made look ordinary by Alessio Forlan who he stopped in 10 (Macklin stopped him in 8 since) and he took a young kid (in Prince Aaron) apart in 2. His subsequent fight vs. Eastman was incredibly close and he looked nothing more than ordinary.

When Don Turner was taken in to train him, Duddy was supposed to come on in leaps and bounds, yet he has continued to look ordinary and has failed to implement the strategies which they have publicised.

Lee on the other hand has done exactly what has been asked of him. In the fights he's won he has either stopped or comprehensively beaten each man and he has had no major scare as of yet.

Although I would like to see both men succeed I feel only one will and It has to be Lee.