Thread: Someone's top 10 Super Middleweight Rankings:you agree?

http://boxingtalk.com/pag/article14815.html

I thought the rankings were pretty good. I'd probably have Mundine above Bute based on his opposition but it's no biggie.

I think Lacy might be a contentious pick but certainly on merit he deserves to be above the other guys.

I thought the rankings were very good overall.

Someone's top 10 Middleweight Rankings:you agree?

So where is Pavlik, Taylor, Arthur and Sturm....










Sorry, I could'nt help myself....

Originally Posted by The Rookie Fan

Someone's top 10 Middleweight Rankings:you agree?

So where is Pavlik, Taylor, Arthur and Sturm....










Sorry, I could'nt help myself....

How long will it be until Ice Cold Boxing comes on here and says 'No they fight at 160 lbs and this is a 168 lb list' ? :P

1 Joe Calzaghe
2 Mikkel Kessler
3 Anthony Mundine
4 Lucian Bute
5 Jeff Lacy
6 Carl Froch
7 Denis Inkin
8 Allan Green
9 Librado Andrade
10 Sakio Bika

Originally Posted by El Gamo

http://boxingtalk.com/pag/article14815.html

It's a good list of SMW but I don't agree with it.

What's Miranda doing in the top 10?
What's Pascal doing in the top 10?
Their just getting their feet wet in the division but certainly I don't they've hit top 10. Top 15 yes I would agree.

Another thing that stands out is both Lacy & Andrade fought the top SMW's at that time they both lost. Since then Lacys fought Tsypko & Peter while Andrades fought Muller & Mack. Why have Lacy at #5 but Andrade #11? theres a 6 space gap between 2 fighters who have possibly fought the same route but 1 has looked better then the other and even then he's rated lower?

Heres my list of the top 10:
Joe
Kess
Bute
Mundine
Lacy
Andrade
Inkin
Froch
Green
Berrio

Bika, Tsypko, Brahemer, Miranda, Pascal.