Thread: Best fighter around?

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Since Mayweather retired, It's gotta be Zab Judah.

Originally Posted by frozensolid_702

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Since Mayweather retired, It's gotta be Zab Judah.

Agreed, although I still feel John Ruiz will take over soon

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Well since Mayweather has retired its Pacquiao end of he has the better wins than any other top 10 P4P fighter, plus he has more achievements winning titles in 4 weight classes not a hard choice for me personally.

Originally Posted by ICB

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Well since Mayweather has retired its Pacquiao end of he has the better wins than any other top 10 P4P fighter, plus he has more achievements winning titles in 4 weight classes not a hard choice for me personally.

Yeah naturally its Manny as he was second P4P on pretty much any list going

yeah i think that Pac man wins by default. he has the better resume. although i see Cotto and Calzaghe not to far behind Pac. BUT i can definetly see Judah in the mix too.

Originally Posted by ICB

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Well since Mayweather has retired its Pacquiao end of he has the better wins than any other top 10 P4P fighter, plus he has more achievements winning titles in 4 weight classes not a hard choice for me personally.

I THOUGHT YOU WERE TAKING A BREAK ICE AFTER YOUR THREAD ?

Pacman I would say

Would love to be able to say Joe but I can't

Maybe after tonight

Originally Posted by frozensolid_702

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Since Mayweather retired, It's gotta be Zab Judah.

Physical talent? Yes mental toughness? No

but in reality there is no such thing as a "best fighter around" right now.

There is no fighter that can DO IT ALL.

The fighters now do great in one aspect and fail in others in the ring.

The closest thing you had to a best all around fighter was Mayweather, and you didn't know how to appreciate him

I think people underestimate exactly what PACMAN has done , hes moved up in weight alot, and it not easy at the lower weights.

He may not be the perfect boxer , but he is the best all round fighter for me , based on who he has fought and defeated.

Calzaghe is near the end and i think Marques was stiffed twice against Pacquiao so im going with Miguel Cotto i think the kid has it all.

Other than that i dont see many elite fighters under 30yo with even 50% of his skill set other decent elite under 30yo is Kelly Pavlik and that isnt much.

cotto i feel yeah best p4p but then i think is he chinny? torres hurt and dropped him, chop chop hurt him, i hope im not being a pesimist on boxing right now but there is a lack of amazing talent right now, Someone name somebody who just blows your mind with ability. I cant its a shame.

If Pac man loses tonight i would have Calzaghe top.Cotto if he wins his next fight he can not be far behind them in my book he is always up for the big fights and he never disappoints.

Originally Posted by frozensolid_702

Originally Posted by feeney

Right now who would you say pound for pound, I dont think calzaghe i like him but think he choses fights carefully. Pac man? im not sure? I like cotto and if he beats margarito who knows he doesnt duck anybody.

Since Mayweather retired, It's gotta be Zab Judah.

Kind Judah has always been p4p king with or without mayweather.