decided to properly sit down and score this fight this morning, ignoring the commentry and Ledermans cards, i can only see it as a 115-113 score for Trinidad,

i had it like this

Tito - 1,4,8,9,10,11,12

Oscar - 2,3,5,6,7

just wondering how other people here had the fight ?

Originally Posted by hitmanhatton

decided to properly sit down and score this fight this morning, ignoring the commentry and Ledermans cards, i can only see it as a 115-113 score for Trinidad,

i had it like this

Tito - 1,4,8,9,10,11,12

Oscar - 2,3,5,6,7

just wondering how other people here had the fight ?

I had it the same. No matter how many times I watch the fight I just can't see all the punches that Lampley said De La Hoya was landing. George Foremann also had some surprising commentary in the fight

I had the fight a draw although i can't find my scorecard, so i can't tell you the exact rounds i gave to each fighter.

i think the round DLH won he dominated but he just didnt do it often enough, ICB, i can see a draw as a possibility as the first round was close and could have easilly gone to Oscar i cant see another of those rounds that you could give him though for him to win

i had tito by a round i think

Are you fucking kidding me, are you guys the same people who think Dela Hoya beat Floyd Mayweather.

Oscar toally outboxed Tito, Tito didn't land anyhting all fight, I hate how people seem to think coming forward wins fights, because it doesn't, Landing the bettter shots does, and Oscar clearly outboxed Tito, it wasn't even close.Tito didn't land anyhting in the first round, hence why Oscar won the round, along with every other round in the first 9 rounds of the fight.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Are you fucking kidding me, are you guys the same people who think Dela Hoya beat Floyd Mayweather.

Oscar toally outboxed Tito, Tito didn't land anyhting all fight, I hate how people seem to think coming forward wins fights, because it doesn't, Landing the bettter shots does, and Oscar clearly outboxed Tito, it wasn't even close.Tito didn't land anyhting in the first round, hence why Oscar won the round, along with every other round in the first 9 rounds of the fight.

so you didnt give him round 4 , although all 3 judges did and Oscar loving HBO did also

Havent got my scorecard handy but I did do one at the time. I remember I had it all on the last round and Tito clearly wanted it more.

I think Oscar had the beating of Trinidad in that fight but threw it away . It was more a case of Oscar finding a way to lose than Tito finding a way to win IMO .

Tito didn't do anything for most of the fight, even at the end it wasn't Oscar, being scared, it was him knowing the fight was in the bag, just boxing smart. This was one of two fights they robbed from Oscar.

It depends who you gave the early rounds to because ODH won the middle rounds, bloodying Tito's nose but won the latter rounds. Although the early rounds were not exciting I gave them just to Tito for pressuring the fight. I had him winning just.

Tito was pressuring, Oscar was punching, and landing. I think people need to watch this fight again.

Originally Posted by Taeth

Are you fucking kidding me, are you guys the same people who think Dela Hoya beat Floyd Mayweather.

Oscar toally outboxed Tito, Tito didn't land anyhting all fight, I hate how people seem to think coming forward wins fights, because it doesn't, Landing the bettter shots does, and Oscar clearly outboxed Tito, it wasn't even close.Tito didn't land anyhting in the first round, hence why Oscar won the round, along with every other round in the first 9 rounds of the fight.

I had Floyd Mayweather beating ODLH by 4 rounds, but i don't see what this has to do with this debate. ODLH won his rounds more clearly and landed more punches, but that doesn't mean anything considering this is RBR.

I had ODLH 6-3 after 9 rounds which i think is very fair, then Tito took over and won the remaining 3 rounds comfortably. Making it 6-6 on my card.

I thought Oscar won the fight hands down Tito did nothing to deserve the win because of that win is why he is even mention with Oscar. Oscar Clearly outboxed him and he was robbed but o well its boxing and it happens to everyone. The only people taht i thought beat Oscar Clearly were Mosley at welter weight, Hopkins and Mayweather. But i while say only person to beat him in prime was Mosley. Never thought that Oscar really ever got dominated in a fight but that is just a thought.

Originally Posted by Mr140

I thought Oscar won the fight hands down Tito did nothing to deserve the win because of that win is why he is even mention with Oscar. Oscar Clearly outboxed him and he was robbed but o well its boxing and it happens to everyone. The only people taht i thought beat Oscar Clearly were Mosley at welter weight, Hopkins and Mayweather. But i while say only person to beat him in prime was Mosley. Never thought that Oscar really ever got dominated in a fight but that is just a thought.

No one was robbed i hate that term used in a close fight like this, and for the record i thought Pernell Whitaker beat a prime ODLH.

Well i sure the hell did not and he was robbed should of won the fight with out the last rounds he was clearly beating Tito.