Originally Posted by
ICB
Originally Posted by
PRIDE OF BOSTON
Antonio Margarito can and will beat everyone in the division except Clottey...
Josh will be the man come 2010!
Funny enough POB i have mixed feelings about Joshua Clottey, i think he is overrated and underrated at the same time. He is overrated by hardcore fans by how well he actually can do at Welterweight, and he is underrated because he is virtually unknown to armchair fans.
To me when i look at Joshua Clottey i see a solid fighter, with a good chin a good all rounder with good countering skills. But theres nothing about him thats great or special in anyway, plus he has stamina issues and he goes into a shell at times aswell.
I think he loses to
Paul Williams, Antonio Margarito, Miguel Cotto, Andre Berto, and possibly Luis Collazo. I think he can compete with most of the top Welterweights, but i can't see him beating most of em except Kermit Cintron.
Wow...
Talk about underrating
With all due respect I have to wholeheartedly disagree with a few of your statments. Although known as a good counterpuncher he is still under rated in this respect. I find that clottey will fight at different paces for different people. I agree with the stamina issues and that also explains going into a shell... But c'mon....
Williams... you never know. I don't like Williams all that much but is he atop the division? Sure. He'll give anyone problems but any of the ones you mentioned baring Collazo can beat Williams if the workrate stays up. He just doesn't overly impress me.
Margarito would have been beaten by Clottey should he not have hurt his hand(s). This just goes to show how great a counter puncher he is... To be able to stifle a guy like antonio margarito, you don't need to be a good counter puncher... You need to be a GREAT counterpuncher.
Cotto would be a great fight and Cotto also would be the favorite. Cotto boxes superbly but I think Clottey on a good night could take cotto as well. Clottey's power is also underrated.
Andre Berto with his leaky defense would get countered all night and probably go down a few times as well... Berto, talk about overrated(though I though he showed great skill and grew up alot in the Forbes fight) he's not even close toready for Clottey. Josh 'ud have him on his back more then once in their fight.
Collazo
Bookmarks