Thread: Who wins in a fight between....

thought id get a little game going whereby you have to answer the question to the original fight and then suggest one of your own

for example:

Hatton v Duran:


I think duran would take him inside 8rounds....

leonard v robinson


-----------------------------------------------------------------------

i`ll start....


hagler v calzaghe

Hagler Calzaghe is a tough call. As long as Hagler does his homework, and can handle the extra weight, I think he is too tough for calzaghe. Calzaghe won't be able to hurt him.

Benitez - Trinidad ?

Ha ha, this is just to stir shiit up, Calzaghe v Hagler, Hagler was good but hes too small and easy to hit for Joe.

How about this, Marciano v Dempsey, that would just be a war!!

leonard vs robinson

SRL ud

Originally Posted by ross

Ha ha, this is just to stir shiit up, Calzaghe v Hagler, Hagler was good but hes too small and easy to hit for Joe.

How about this, Marciano v Dempsey, that would just be a war!!

Marciano KO 6 Dempsey

Ali v Lewis

Originally Posted by Master

Originally Posted by ross

Ha ha, this is just to stir shiit up, Calzaghe v Hagler, Hagler was good but hes too small and easy to hit for Joe.

How about this, Marciano v Dempsey, that would just be a war!!

Marciano KO 6 Dempsey

Ali v Lewis

Ali by sd

Morales - Marquez

Morales - Marquez

Morales SD


Hearns - Benn

Originally Posted by CGM

Hagler Calzaghe is a tough call. As long as Hagler does his homework, and can handle the extra weight, I think he is too tough for calzaghe. Calzaghe won't be able to hurt him.

Benitez - Trinidad ?

Trinidad TKO 10 or UD, i think Benitez would make Trinidad work but would be too small to handle Tito's punches for the full 12 rnds

Ivan Calderon Vs Ricardo Lopez 108

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

Originally Posted by CGM

Hagler Calzaghe is a tough call. As long as Hagler does his homework, and can handle the extra weight, I think he is too tough for calzaghe. Calzaghe won't be able to hurt him.

Benitez - Trinidad ?

Trinidad TKO 10 or UD, i think Benitez would make Trinidad work but would be too small to handle Tito's punches for the full 12 rnds

Ivan Calderon Vs Ricardo Lopez 108

Lopez by unanimous decision

Aaron Pryor vs Floyd Mayweather Jr

PBF would slip Aaron's punches and potshot his way to a UD, although I thought Pryor was at his awesome best against Alexis Arguello.

Originally Posted by clintuk

Morales - Marquez

Morales SD


Hearns - Benn

Gotta go with Hearns. Both huge punchers with questionable punch resistance but Hearns fought the better opposition and prime for prime I go Hearns KO 6.

Tyson Vs Prime George Foreman

Originally Posted by rjj tszyu

Originally Posted by clintuk

Morales - Marquez

Morales SD


Hearns - Benn

Gotta go with Hearns. Both huge punchers with questionable punch resistance but Hearns fought the better opposition and prime for prime I go Hearns KO 6.

Tyson Vs Prime George Foreman

Foreman by KO its Joe Frazier all over again.

Roy Jones vs Ray Leonard

Of course there's the size difference, but IMO SRL was a more complete boxer than RJJ. At the same weight, SRL by comfortable decision.

Originally Posted by jon09

Originally Posted by rjj tszyu

Originally Posted by clintuk

Morales - Marquez

Morales SD


Hearns - Benn

Gotta go with Hearns. Both huge punchers with questionable punch resistance but Hearns fought the better opposition and prime for prime I go Hearns KO 6.

Tyson Vs Prime George Foreman

Foreman by KO its Joe Frazier all over again.

Roy Jones vs Ray Leonard

Roy Jones (Probably UD). Faster, bigger and more powerful. Also his unorthodoxy would be the only way to baffle a boxing genius like Leonard.

Agree with the Tyson - Foreman post good call!

Joe Frazier - Rocky Marciano

Originally Posted by rjj tszyu

Originally Posted by clintuk

Morales - Marquez

Morales SD


Hearns - Benn

Gotta go with Hearns. Both huge punchers with questionable punch resistance but Hearns fought the better opposition and prime for prime I go Hearns KO 6.

Tyson Vs Prime George Foreman

Its funny,I think Foreman in his early comeback stood a better chance at beating Tyson than his rough & rugged 70's version.Just a study in tempered patience and focus.It almost came off,but Foreman could not get him in the ring.That would have beed great whatever version went head to head