Thread: Thrilla in Manilla - The Judges Scorecards hmm

Does anyone agree with judges scorecards in this fight? All 3 had Ali up by a big margin.


Carlos Padilla 60-66 | judge: Larry Nadayag 62-66 | judge: Alfredo Quiazon 62-67


I presume those cards mean 10-4, 8-4-2 and 8-3-3?

I just watched this fight on ESPN and had Frazier clearly up after 14. I had it 9-5.

There were only 2 close rounds where I had trouble finding a winner but tbh I had to give them both to Frazier cos he was controlling the pace of the fight, putting extra effort in and throwing more. But if you score those 2 close ones to Ali you can have a 7-7. 8-6 Frazier is fine too. I thought Frazier outworked and outhustled Ali for the most part. Did judges just give rounds to Ali cos he was Ali or something?

I dont see how Ali is ahead let alone walking it? Frazier clearly won 7 rounds for me, totally blitzed all the mid rounds imo.

Originally Posted by J_C

Does anyone agree with judges scorecards in this fight? All 3 had Ali up by a big margin.


Carlos Padilla 60-66 | judge: Larry Nadayag 62-66 | judge: Alfredo Quiazon 62-67


I presume those cards mean 10-4, 8-4-2 and 8-3-3?

I just watched this fight on ESPN and had Frazier clearly up after 14. I had it 9-5.

There were only 2 close rounds where I had trouble finding a winner but tbh I had to give them both to Frazier cos he was controlling the pace of the fight, putting extra effort in and throwing more. But if you score those 2 close ones to Ali you can have a 7-7. 8-6 Frazier is fine too. I thought Frazier outworked and outhustled Ali for the most part. Did judges just give rounds to Ali cos he was Ali or something?

I dont see how Ali is ahead let alone walking it? Frazier clearly won 7 rounds for me, totally blitzed all the mid rounds imo.

I had Ali ahead but not by much, I felt his accuracy and sharp punching earned him most the early rounds, then Frazier came back strong and made up for lost ground, IMO the fight was dead even, the way it ended just lets you know how close it was

Frazier basically blind has his corner throw in the towel unknowing of the fact that Ali wasn't planning on coming out for the 15th, both men were equal rivals, and although Ali earned two victories IMO neither was really better than the other when it came to pitting just the two of them against each other

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

Originally Posted by J_C

Does anyone agree with judges scorecards in this fight? All 3 had Ali up by a big margin.


Carlos Padilla 60-66 | judge: Larry Nadayag 62-66 | judge: Alfredo Quiazon 62-67


I presume those cards mean 10-4, 8-4-2 and 8-3-3?

I just watched this fight on ESPN and had Frazier clearly up after 14. I had it 9-5.

There were only 2 close rounds where I had trouble finding a winner but tbh I had to give them both to Frazier cos he was controlling the pace of the fight, putting extra effort in and throwing more. But if you score those 2 close ones to Ali you can have a 7-7. 8-6 Frazier is fine too. I thought Frazier outworked and outhustled Ali for the most part. Did judges just give rounds to Ali cos he was Ali or something?

I dont see how Ali is ahead let alone walking it? Frazier clearly won 7 rounds for me, totally blitzed all the mid rounds imo.

I had Ali ahead but not by much, I felt his accuracy and sharp punching earned him most the early rounds, then Frazier came back strong and made up for lost ground, IMO the fight was dead even, the way it ended just lets you know how close it was

Frazier basically blind has his corner throw in the towel unknowing of the fact that Ali wasn't planning on coming out for the 15th, both men were equal rivals, and although Ali earned two victories IMO neither was really better than the other when it came to pitting just the two of them against each other

Yes, they just seemed to have styles that evened each other out. Ali might have the edge in terms of official wins, but in terms of overall rounds won, they are pretty neck and neck.

I don't know why they had to fight in Manilla, the place is a cauldron at its coolest. Not sensible to have a 15 round HW fight there at all.

Ali was clearly winning this fight and landing more frequently, the damage to Joe is evidence enough. Joe fought his heart out, but he was way behind in this fight, i have no issue with the scorecards, in fact it could've been wider. Joe was in trouble from the first round and was lucky to escape the second round. Joe was fighting from memory for the last 6 or 7 rounds.

I have Ali winning rounds 1-5, 11, 13, and 14. So, 8-6 for Ali.

I think that an argument can be made that Frazier won round 5.

But I also think an argument can be made that Ali won round 12.

If I were to score those two rounds even, I would still have it 7-5-2 for Ali.

You need to remember that Ali got a head start in his fights back then.

If a round was close Ali got it, pretty much every time.