Thread: Who is up in the JMM-Pac trilogy?

These are my scorecards

1st fight :114-111 pacman
2nd fight : 114-113 Pacman
3rd fight : 115-114 Marquez

18-17-1 in rounds for Marquez
The knockdowns made the difference for me

IMO, it should be 2-1 in fights in favour od Pac

3-0 for Marquez, at worst it's 2-0-1 in Marquez' favor

113-113 Draw
114-113 Marquez
117-114 Marquez

20-12-4 Marquez.

If you wana give Pac all 4 draw rounds (I think most tend to in the pick em rounds between these 2) then including the knockdowns, thats a stalemate.

many close rounds between these fighters. That's why , anyone calling a robbery in any of these fights is crazy. It depends what you look at in fights, when you're a judge.

I am happy for the Pac wins but I consider them both as equal. Draw on all three.

And kudos to Marquez for maintaining equal status with Pacquiao in the third fight given his age.

These are my scorecards after rewatching each fight.

1st fight

1 Pacquiao 10-6
2 Pacquiao 10-9
3 Marquez 10-9
4 Marquez 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Marquez 10-9
7 Pacquiao 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Marquez 10-9
10 Pacquiao 10-9
11 Marquez 10-9
12 Marquez 10-9


113-112 JMM

2nd fight

1 Pacquiao 10-9
2 Marquez 10-9
3 Pacquiao 10-8
4 Pacquiao 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Marquez 10-9
7 Marquez 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Pacquiao 10-9
10 Pacquiao 10-9
11 Marquez 10-9
12 Marquez 10-9

114-113 JMM

3rd fight

1 Even 10-10
2 Marquez 10-9
3 Marquez 10-9
4 Pacquiao 10-9
5 Marquez 10-9
6 Pacquiao 10-9
7 Marquez 10-9
8 Marquez 10-9
9 Marquez 10-9
10 Marquez 10-9
11 Pacquiao 10-9
12 Pacquiao 10-9

116-113 JMM

I havent seen the first fight in a long time, i remember thinking marquez won


I watched the second fight the other night and pac won, i actually think it was by a clear 2 rounds, nothing controversial about that fight


And i havent seen 3

Is this supposed to be a million dollar question..

Of course it's Marquez. Easy..