Thread: Margarito vs Mayorga?

Prime for prime it would have been amazing, much along the lines of a Gatti-Hatton type fantasy war.

If the fight happened right now I don't know who wins, Mayorga could pull it off but could he make weight

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

This fight should have happened 03 right after Margarito beat 6head lewis but Don King wasnt going to let Mayorga anywhere near the killa..

I guess this fight still makes sense for several reasons. I mean where else can they go at this point..

Margarito beats Mayorgas ass anyday of the week but with his eye, u just never know... He needs to just retire. I dont want Mayorga winning via a doctor stoppage like Cotto did..

Margarito is just in a bad position right now.. It's the eye..

This is rubbish.

Mayorga was beating the top pound for pound fighter in the world and taking other highly ranked unbeaten fighters 0 too. Margarito was getting Stopped by Daniel Santos...

Margarito needs to retire.

His eye swelled as soon as Cotto starting making contact and it's only going to get worse if he continues.

Originally Posted by ross

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

This fight should have happened 03 right after Margarito beat 6head lewis but Don King wasnt going to let Mayorga anywhere near the killa..

I guess this fight still makes sense for several reasons. I mean where else can they go at this point..

Margarito beats Mayorgas ass anyday of the week but with his eye, u just never know... He needs to just retire. I dont want Mayorga winning via a doctor stoppage like Cotto did..

Margarito is just in a bad position right now.. It's the eye..

This is rubbish.

Mayorga was beating the top pound for pound fighter in the world and taking other highly ranked unbeaten fighters 0 too. Margarito was getting Stopped by Daniel Santos...

There aint nothing rubbish about it and your timeline if off. Mayorga lost his titles to Spinks at the end of 03 and Margarito beat 6head Lewis 2 months after.. Margarito was the WBO champ at the time and a fight Mayorga would have been perfect. Instead, he chose to fight Eric Mitchell and ended up in a big money fight with Tito.. I understand him and King were chasing the money but alot of fans were clamoring for Mayorga-Margarito..

Originally Posted by Manos de Piedra

I want to reply to this thread but might get in the way of the nuclear fall out above.
Anyway, this would be a great fight. the build up would be crazy with the stuff these two would come out with. As for the fight I don't know how it would turn out but I'll be rooting for Mayorga because he will have the funnier insults.

Oh hell, Mayorga would have a FIELD DAY with Margarito. He's got too much material to work with.... LMAO!!!! I can imagine it now.....

He'd get on Margacheato's ass on everything from his plaster casts to his pointy chin hair, to his sometimes Pacquiao wannabe looks, to his getting his ass kicked in his last few fights. Then.... he'd turn his sights on MRS. Margacheato and slide in a few inappropriate comments, and REALLY get under Margacheato's skin.

Only difference here being..... in the real fight, Mayorga would proceed to kick his ass, to add insult to injury. Can we get a promoter out there to make this fight? Please?

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Manos de Piedra

I want to reply to this thread but might get in the way of the nuclear fall out above.
Anyway, this would be a great fight. the build up would be crazy with the stuff these two would come out with. As for the fight I don't know how it would turn out but I'll be rooting for Mayorga because he will have the funnier insults.

Oh hell, Mayorga would have a FIELD DAY with Margarito. He's got too much material to work with.... LMAO!!!! I can imagine it now.....

He'd get on Margacheato's ass on everything from his plaster casts to his pointy chin hair, to his sometimes Pacquiao wannabe looks, to his getting his ass kicked in his last few fights. Then.... he'd turn his sights on MRS. Margacheato and slide in a few inappropriate comments, and REALLY get under Margacheato's skin.

Only difference here being..... in the real fight, Mayorga would proceed to kick his ass, to add insult to injury. Can we get a promoter out there to make this fight? Please?

I wish I was as sure of Mayorga winning as you are and Mayorga is my #1 favorite fighter

Mrs. Margarito was looking pretty hot during the Cotto fight, in a Morticia Adams sorta way lol

Damn is she pale !

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Manos de Piedra

I want to reply to this thread but might get in the way of the nuclear fall out above.
Anyway, this would be a great fight. the build up would be crazy with the stuff these two would come out with. As for the fight I don't know how it would turn out but I'll be rooting for Mayorga because he will have the funnier insults.

Oh hell, Mayorga would have a FIELD DAY with Margarito. He's got too much material to work with.... LMAO!!!! I can imagine it now.....

He'd get on Margacheato's ass on everything from his plaster casts to his pointy chin hair, to his sometimes Pacquiao wannabe looks, to his getting his ass kicked in his last few fights. Then.... he'd turn his sights on MRS. Margacheato and slide in a few inappropriate comments, and REALLY get under Margacheato's skin.

Only difference here being..... in the real fight, Mayorga would proceed to kick his ass, to add insult to injury. Can we get a promoter out there to make this fight? Please?

I wish I was as sure of Mayorga winning as you are and Mayorga is my #1 favorite fighter

Mrs. Margarito was looking pretty hot during the Cotto fight, in a Morticia Adams sorta way lol

Damn is she pale !

Your a cool guy Tito and I like you but you are kinda trollin right now. Do you honestly believe that Mayorga beats Margarito? Ur hate for Margo seems a bit too extreme bruh.. I understand that he made your hero quit on his knees but let's be reasonable..

Mayorga is tailor made for him dude. Id like to see him stick his chin out again cuz Margarito would take full advantage of that and he wouldnt be intimidated like Forrest either.. Forrest was a mean puncher but because he was intimidated, he couldnt hurt Mayorga even with a free shot..

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Manos de Piedra

I want to reply to this thread but might get in the way of the nuclear fall out above.
Anyway, this would be a great fight. the build up would be crazy with the stuff these two would come out with. As for the fight I don't know how it would turn out but I'll be rooting for Mayorga because he will have the funnier insults.

Oh hell, Mayorga would have a FIELD DAY with Margarito. He's got too much material to work with.... LMAO!!!! I can imagine it now.....

He'd get on Margacheato's ass on everything from his plaster casts to his pointy chin hair, to his sometimes Pacquiao wannabe looks, to his getting his ass kicked in his last few fights. Then.... he'd turn his sights on MRS. Margacheato and slide in a few inappropriate comments, and REALLY get under Margacheato's skin.

Only difference here being..... in the real fight, Mayorga would proceed to kick his ass, to add insult to injury. Can we get a promoter out there to make this fight? Please?

I wish I was as sure of Mayorga winning as you are and Mayorga is my #1 favorite fighter

Mrs. Margarito was looking pretty hot during the Cotto fight, in a Morticia Adams sorta way lol

Damn is she pale !

Your a cool guy Tito and I like you but you are kinda trollin right now. Do you honestly believe that Mayorga beats Margarito? Ur hate for Margo seems a bit too extreme bruh.. I understand that he made your hero quit on his knees but let's be reasonable..

Mayorga is tailor made for him dude. Id like to see him stick his chin out again cuz Margarito would take full advantage of that and he wouldnt be intimidated like Forrest either.. Forrest was a mean puncher but because he was intimidated, he couldnt hurt Mayorga even with a free shot..

he did it against Trinidad and Tito hit a hell of a lot harder than Tony

Mayorga was beating Mosley until he got KO'd while Tony just got the shit kicked out of him.

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Manos de Piedra

I want to reply to this thread but might get in the way of the nuclear fall out above.
Anyway, this would be a great fight. the build up would be crazy with the stuff these two would come out with. As for the fight I don't know how it would turn out but I'll be rooting for Mayorga because he will have the funnier insults.

Oh hell, Mayorga would have a FIELD DAY with Margarito. He's got too much material to work with.... LMAO!!!! I can imagine it now.....

He'd get on Margacheato's ass on everything from his plaster casts to his pointy chin hair, to his sometimes Pacquiao wannabe looks, to his getting his ass kicked in his last few fights. Then.... he'd turn his sights on MRS. Margacheato and slide in a few inappropriate comments, and REALLY get under Margacheato's skin.

Only difference here being..... in the real fight, Mayorga would proceed to kick his ass, to add insult to injury. Can we get a promoter out there to make this fight? Please?

I wish I was as sure of Mayorga winning as you are and Mayorga is my #1 favorite fighter

Mrs. Margarito was looking pretty hot during the Cotto fight, in a Morticia Adams sorta way lol

Damn is she pale !

Your a cool guy Tito and I like you but you are kinda trollin right now. Do you honestly believe that Mayorga beats Margarito? Ur hate for Margo seems a bit too extreme bruh.. I understand that he made your hero quit on his knees after hitting repeatedly with his plaster casts, which could've potentially ended a lesser man's career but let's be reasonable..

Mayorga is tailor made for him dude. Id like to see him stick his chin out again cuz Margarito would take full advantage of that and he wouldnt be intimidated like Forrest either.. Forrest was a mean puncher but because he was intimidated, he couldnt hurt Mayorga even with a free shot..

Ok, ok.... let me put my objective boxing fan hat on. You're right. Right now Mayorga might not be able to take out Margacheato. His only chance is to connect some wild haymakers on Margacheato's iron chin, and they'd have to be in quick succession. Chances are Margacheato's relentless pressure would eventually get to Mayorga. Had they met in Mayorga's prime, it would've been a hell of a lot more interesting, given Mayorga's volume of punches and better stamina (than he might have now). It's my heart thinking about Mayorga KTFO'ing Margacheato.

But you DID have a slight omission in your comments above, which I've generously fixed for you. No need to thank me.



You ARE right about another thing, tho.
My hate for Margacheato IS a bit extreme. I'm not too fond of low-life scumbag cheaters who once they've been caught show no remorse whatsoever. Other than that, I've got no issues with the douche-bag.

Lol this fight would be so fun to watch. I got Mayorga winning though pretty clearly aswell.

Should have happened years ago when Mayorga was the welterweight champion. But it kind of still makes sense now for the 2 war horses. Put me down for Mayorga to take Margarito out

Yes ! Everyone is all about Mayorga in this thread.

Its refreshing to have so many fellow Mayorga supporters for once.

Margarito is so hated that he transcends the former biggest bad guy in boxing.

For me I only need look at their respective fights with Mosley. Mayorga was years past his best and notorious for not training and was bulling Mosley around until he ran out of steam very late.

Margarito on the other hand was seen as some sort of terminator in his prime coming off the battering of Cotto and Mosley kicked the fuck out of him.

If Mayorga had Margaritos work ethic in training there would be no question. Its only ever been his training and fight schedule that has let him down. He either wouldnt train properly or in the Mosley fight which I think he did train well for, he just had such long lay offs between action that he wouldnt really get in to any rythm for a few rounds then it was too late as he wouldnt have the right stamina to carry on.

The beating he took from Tito when he wasnt fit was unbelievable. Id say he has a better chin than Margarito too. I also doubt that Mayorga would lose to Santos. Margaritos only strength was his strength. His ability to boil down to welter. Like Hatton at light welter.

Originally Posted by ElTerribleMorales

Originally Posted by FinitoElDinamita

This fight should have happened 03 right after Margarito beat 6head lewis but Don King wasnt going to let Mayorga anywhere near the killa..

I guess this fight still makes sense for several reasons. I mean where else can they go at this point..

Margarito beats Mayorgas ass anyday of the week but with his eye, u just never know... He needs to just retire. I dont want Mayorga winning via a doctor stoppage like Cotto did..

Margarito is just in a bad position right now.. It's the eye..

even if Margarito's eye wouldn't have swelled up he wasn't doing anything effective with both eyes, he wasn't cutting off the ring, he wasn't catching Cotto and he had no power (obviously it's still in CA), instead of a stoppage he would have lost by a shut out even with both good eyes, Margarito not being able to see in one eye has nothing to do with the fact that he didn't have any power, and if anything he was landing more (albeit nothing effective) in the later rounds after the eye was swollen shut, the only thing the eye is now is an excuse, lets not forget Margarito said over and over that the eye was not an issue, Margarito's doctor said that the eye was better than it was before, if it was all bullshit than the guy has no one else to blame but himself for going blind in his right eye, unless he want's to go blind, retire cause now that he's fully found out with the eye and the lack of power due to not having his loaded wraps well he really has nothing to go on, maybe should just fight some more tomato cans in Mexico or something, hell him and JCC Jr can both do it on the same card and bill it Attack of the Killer Tomato's

too hard to say

ever tried boxing at elite level with one eye?

the eye was the decisive factor in that fight, yes cotto was dominating, but so was he is the first fight