Who Wins Pound for Pound between these two in the ring!?

Margacheato's too strong and durable. Bigger, too.

Pound for pound just based on records Hatton, but in an actual fight Margarito. I hate Margarito with a passion but Hatton has 0 business of ever being int he same ring with Margarito. Hatton could barely take Collazo's punches, Margarito would murder Hatton.......yes seriously murder him, I'm being quite literal here.

In a battle of pressure fighter vs pressure fighter usually the bigger more durable fighter wins.

But against Urango the bigger stronger fighter hatton did manager to come out winning about 11 of 12 rounds! Just playing devils advocate

Originally Posted by oakleyno1

But against Urango the bigger stronger fighter hatton did manager to come out winning about 11 of 12 rounds! Just playing devils advocate

At 140, at 147 Hatton looked horrible. Margarito fought at 147 and up.....even if it's a catchweight of 145 Hatton gets massacred.

Margarito would be too big, too strong, and probably a better fighter as well. Hatton couldn't hurt him, it would not be physically possible, so Margarito would just walk over him.

Hatton's probably to small but if size wasnt an issue I think hatton would choose to box in this fight and pull it off

I'd take pound for pound to mean assuming that somehow Margarito wasn't bigger Anyone's fight in that case as Hatton had more/better tools and was just as tenacious for a time. If ever it had possibly happened I agree that Margarito would beat him up and all though, he was a bigger stronger man that could not have been hurt there. Hatton vs Cotto at 140 would've been much more interesting.

In the P4P world, Hatton was the better all round fighter and he would batter Margarita. Hatton achieved way more in boxing. In real life it would not happen.