I admit mine were a bit extreme

I actually rate Castillo much higher than most. He does have some early losses that are held against him too much IMO by some, not so dissimilar to Pacquaio.

I do think Baldomir was a very poor titlist. And Zab is not much. And Gatti was never anywhere near elite. Maybe I believe more of this than I thought Actually some of Floyd's earlier stuff is probably a bit underrated.