Thread: Latest p4p rankings. Agree or disagree?

Biggest gripe is having Wlad in there. P4P by it's definition assumes that every fighter is the same size and weight. If Wlad was a 5'8 welterweight, he would struggle to be in the top ten at 147 imo.

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Originally Posted by TitoFan

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Originally Posted by TitoFan

C'mon.... between you and me. You know Canelo has no business in the top 10 p4p list.



Take off your biased hat and put on your knowledgeable boxing hat.... that's right.
Now think about it.

Just trying to be helpful here.

A victory over Austin Trout. You know the guy who had his way with your Miguel Cotto means a lot more than wins over Matthew Macklin and Curtis Stevens combined. It's that simple. If you think otherwise than there really is no hope for you.

One meaningful victory, VD. ONE. There's a conga line of boxers out there with more than just the one meaningful victory who are a hell of a lot more deserving for a spot in the top ten p4p than Canelo.

Canelo is still on the way up, VD. But there's no shortcuts into the elite. That shit's got to be earned over time, and with a hell of a lot more than one meaningful opponent.

Golovkin ain't even got one yet. And you got him up there. You can't even follow your own stupid logic. I'm a big fan of Triple G. But lets be real here. Stevens and Macklin ain't big wins.

Yeah... you're right.
They're nowhere as big as a shot Shane Mosley and an undersized Josesito Lopez.

But hey it's my mistake.
Just goes to show you can't be civil to a proven moron.

I'm gonna make this question as idiot proof as possible for you. You have Golovkin over Alvarez on the list. Which of Golovkin wins is better than Alvarez win over Austin Trout? All you gotta do state a name. That's it. Just a name. Don't even try and a give a reason why you think it's better. You'll only embarrass yourself further with your nonsense. So just state a name. There's no way you can fuck this up. Just give a name

All of them. Trout was robbed

Originally Posted by ono

Biggest gripe is having Wlad in there. P4P by it's definition assumes that every fighter is the same size and weight. If Wlad was a 5'8 welterweight, he would struggle to be in the top ten at 147 imo.

Stupidest thing I ever heard. If hearns was a 5'8 Welterweight he would have been shit.

My 10

Floyd
Ward
Bradley
JMM
Wlad
Garcia
Garcia
Rigo
GGG
Kovalev