Scottish boxing is buzzing at the moment, who's the best Scot out there just now?

Thus far I'm behind 2-1 in votes.* AA would have been my second choice though.

Welcome Hebman, good poll and have a cool click.

I hope Ricky Burns lives up to his potential,if he does he will be up there at the top in a couple of years.
I vted AA by the way!

3-3 in votes now, I'm genuinely surprised.

And I'll remember you Gogs when Scott steps up...

Originally Posted by Wallace

3-3 in votes now, I'm genuinely surprised.

And I'll remember you Gogs when Scott steps up...

C'mon m8,don't hold me to it! It's a difficult one for me cos i've been a huge fan of Scotts for years.It's just a pity most folk on here never saw him fight when he would actually BOX and he is damn good at it when he wants to!I think thats what swung it for me for Alex because he seems to have slightly more in his arsenal now.Plus he's a really decent,down to earth guy if you meet him.......and he's from Edinburgh (see,local bias )

Originally Posted by gogs67

Originally Posted by Wallace

3-3 in votes now, I'm genuinely surprised.

And I'll remember you Gogs when Scott steps up...

C'mon m8,don't hold me to it! It's a difficult one for me cos i've been a huge fan of Scotts for years.It's just a pity most folk on here never saw him fight when he would actually BOX and he is damn good at it when he wants to!I think thats what swung it for me for Alex because he seems to have slightly more in his arsenal now.Plus he's a really decent,down to earth guy if you meet him.......and he's from Edinburgh (see,local bias )

I'm only playing Gogs, not serious. It was difficult for me too as I like both boxers. CC for the point on Scotts boxing, agreed completely. I share your bias being more East than West but I feel stronger for Scott as I guess I see him as more of an underdog than Arthur.

Originally Posted by Wallace

Originally Posted by gogs67

Originally Posted by Wallace

3-3 in votes now, I'm genuinely surprised.

And I'll remember you Gogs when Scott steps up...

C'mon m8,don't hold me to it! It's a difficult one for me cos i've been a huge fan of Scotts for years.It's just a pity most folk on here never saw him fight when he would actually BOX and he is damn good at it when he wants to!I think thats what swung it for me for Alex because he seems to have slightly more in his arsenal now.Plus he's a really decent,down to earth guy if you meet him.......and he's from Edinburgh (see,local bias )

I'm only playing Gogs, not serious. It was difficult for me too as I like both boxers. CC for the point on Scotts boxing, agreed completely. I share your bias being more East than West but I feel stronger for Scott as I guess I see him as more of an underdog than Arthur.

I know cc.
I can't believe the stick Scott gets from all sides,Christ,the guy's a 2 time world title holder with 8 world title defences under his belt out of 29 fights! He was an intercontinental title holder after 10 fights and he's never ducked anyone in his career.What does he need to do?

Cheers for the responses people. It's interesting to see so many people going for Alex Arthur.

I picked Alex Arthur cause i was at his last fight and he looked great. Ricky Burns was expected to be KO'd but he fought so well,hopefuly in around 4 or 5 years ther'l be 6 ot 7 Scottish champs.

Originally Posted by Hebman

Cheers for the responses people. It's interesting to see so many people going for Alex Arthur.

Originally Posted by Wallace

Originally Posted by Hebman

Cheers for the responses people. It's interesting to see so many people going for Alex Arthur.

The best is Harrison because he's proven at a better level. Arthur I think is more skilled & has good potential, but he's not mixed with Scotts level of opponents yet.

PS. I would have put Harrison on the Poll, but it doesn't seem to give me an option to vote.

Poll closed sadly!

Originally Posted by gogs67

Poll closed sadly!

Yeah I bet you were gutted...