Originally Posted by marbleheadmaui I thought I'd pick a fight Here's the criteria 1. Great fighters beaten when they were great fighters 2. Division wrecking 3. Ranked fighters beaten 3. Taking on everyone or nearly so 4. Occasional losses top great fighters don't have large impact 5. Losses to less than great fighters when in one's extended prime have a significant impact 6. Judgement is made over one's "extended prime." The longer the prime the better ...