Originally Posted by
mikeeod
Great thread and great choices so far. Jose Luis Lopez was a beast who was in the discussion with Quartey, Tito, and Oscar but wanted to surf and smoke pot more than train (can’t say I blame him). Most of my list are frustrating fighters who had great talent and had great performances when in great shape, but were inconsistent for large portions of their careers.
1. Most heavyweights from the 80s- Page, Dokes, Pinklon Thomas...etc.
2. Ray Mercer- watch his wars with Evander and Lennox, and contrast with his losses to Furgesson and Larry Holmes.
3. Emanuel Augustus: Great fights against Floyd, Ward...etc., and then lose to a nobody due to a lack of focus and condition
4. Riddick Bowe
5. Buster Douglas
6. James Toney
7. Evander- one of my fave fighters who many will initially disagree with me on due to the fact that he was always ripped and a physical specimen, but he disregarded cardio for a few fights. Think of him vs Toney, Lennox Lewis, Vaughn Bean, and the first fight vs Moorer. He was gassing Hardin those fights.
8. Whitaker- late in his career he became a coke monster and partied too much. He was already in the decline vs Oscar and he kept that fight close despite partying most of his camp.