Thread: Gerald Mcclellan vs Joe Calzaghe who wins ??

who wins this ??

good one. its tricky but i think joe had more steam and would survive the early onslaught to win on points.

HMM yer very good match up ICE COLD....Id go for Calzaghe UD.

Originally Posted by cockey cockney

HMM yer very good match up ICE COLD....Id go for Calzaghe UD.

thanks guys i see calzaghe surviving early storm but i reckon calzaghe would get dropped early i dont see calzaghe stopping gerald jackson couldnt move gerald with his punches so doubt calzaghe would but i take calzaghe by ud but i tell u what calzaghe would have to be at his best to beat gerald he wouldnt be able to keep his hands down otherwise night night joe but if we are talking absolute peak calzaghe i take him by ud like i said

Calzaghe UD as long as his hand holds up.

Calzaghe wouldn't make out the second round. G-man by brutal KO.

G-Man would be outboxed.

Nigel Benn did it, so could the Pride of Wales!

Difficult to see anybody standing up to McClellan's overhand right. He had extremely heavy hands, G-Man. And let's face it, Joe will get hit.. he's too square-on.

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Calzaghe wouldn't make out the second round. G-man by brutal KO.

Agreed....Nigel Benn had to Cheat and literally almost have to beat Gerald to death....So Joe dosent have close to the power to keep Gerald at bay, Gerald can Box as well as Knock your azz out...Joe would lose within the 1st 3 rounds by brutal KO.....

Calzaghe would decision him handily...

would have been a good fight, I think JC would survive the early rounds to
win, but if McClellan caught him with a few big shots he could take him out

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Calzaghe wouldn't make out the second round.  G-man by brutal KO.

Agreed....Nigel Benn had to Cheat and literally almost have to beat Gerald to death....So Joe dosent have close to the power to keep Gerald at bay, Gerald can Box as well as Knock your azz out...Joe would lose within the 1st 3 rounds by brutal KO.....

he didnt cheat jt he done few illegal blows here and there but didnt cheat he won fair and square and on that night he was awesome

Mclellan is blind and in a wheel chair, not a fair fight imo.

Mclellan vs Watson is fairer, I'd say Watson because he can almost stand unaided.

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Calzaghe wouldn't make out the second round. G-man by brutal KO.

Agreed....Nigel Benn had to Cheat and literally almost have to beat Gerald to death....So Joe dosent have close to the power to keep Gerald at bay, Gerald can Box as well as Knock your azz out...Joe would lose within the 1st 3 rounds by brutal KO.....

he didnt cheat jt he done few illegal blows here and there but didnt cheat he won fair and square and on that night he was awesome

Rabbit punching and hitting in the back is illegal......Nigel repeatedly fouled Gerald every chance he could Nigel knew what he was doing and the ref let him get away with it....Nigel got the benefit of Home cookin plain and simple!!!!!

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by ICE COLD BOXING

Originally Posted by JT Rock

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Calzaghe wouldn't make out the second round. G-man by brutal KO.

Agreed....Nigel Benn had to Cheat and literally almost have to beat Gerald to death....So Joe dosent have close to the power to keep Gerald at bay, Gerald can Box as well as Knock your azz out...Joe would lose within the 1st 3 rounds by brutal KO.....

he didnt cheat jt he done few illegal blows here and there but didnt cheat he won fair and square and on that night he was awesome

Rabbit punching and hitting in the back is illegal......Nigel repeatedly fouled Gerald every chance he could Nigel knew what he was doing and the ref let him get away with it....Nigel got the benefit of Home cookin plain and simple!!!!!

Mate almost all boxers throw shots behind the head when they are in close, just that in this instance there was a tragic end.