Thread: p4p who beats who?

what if our top 3 p4p fighters fought eachother...considering who's best at what, defensively winky is the best, offensively pac is the best, as for pbf the hybrid, he has a mixture of both this maybe what can win him the matches...

winky
pros; defensive god, veteran boxer, southpaw, hardnose comeforward rally.

cons; k.o power, handspeed compare to pbf & pac, age. no show of improvement already in his prime.

pac
pros; brutal warrior, devestating handspeed combinations. left and right k.o power, conditioned king, p4p yet young and still shows improvement

cons; balance of defense, not yet prove his prime, lacks a technical boxing performance...

pbf
pros,handspeed footwork defensively solid and balanced...condtitioned king, boxing skills...prime but still bringing a few new things.

cons; weight jumping, little by little speed slowing and punching power...may bite on more then he can chew...pressure resistance unknown

this is not saying who should be number 1 but who has what it takes to beat who?

to beat winky
to beat pbf
to beat pac

keep those in mind...

lets stay on modern time pls don't go back digging into how pbf should of lost to castillo bs. or pacs two k.o lost way back b4 christ...or winkys lost...stay on the fighters of today how good they are now.

to beat pbf I believe he needs to be stun, he needs to become hesitant...his hard to hit but to make a fighter stun or hesitant it only takes one punch to slow him down...out of winky and pac? who packs that power punch...?pac...add his speed and stamina and we finally have someone that matches pbfs speed and length of abbility to sustain that activity...add pbfs boxing art can it take away pacs relentless pressure or vise versa...example mab rate his boxing ability? do we bash him and jst say pbf is way better then mab...no but consider it and hopefully don't be bias...

things that can happen...pbf totally outbox the pacman or under heavy fire pbf falls to the relentless pressure of the pacman...

who ever wins it'll be great

to beat winky? imaging pbf and pac a natural middleweight...that takes away winkys advantage in size...wow pac a middleweight scary thought...and the hybrid can winky contend to the speed of the pbf and pac or does the wise veteran wizard get overwhelm?...no way,...to beat winky take pacs right and left stunning power and add pbf boxing art...and combine the twos speed and stamina then that would surely murder the veteran wizard...but no against a middleweight pac vs winky lets take a look...winky a defensive god, pac the hands of brutality...hmm they say to win championships you need a great defense but a great defense vs a great offense?

to beat pac...easy jst underestimate him and say he will lose...no, it takes heart to face this beast...fold under his attack and your dead...Heart a huge factor every legendary fighter has...every great fighter has been tested and prove that warriors heart...some may say all you have to do is outbox the pacman...but how easy is that realistically...u can say u know how fast how strong but its very much a nightmare against pac...win or lose or draw against pac u was tested like never before...pbf boxing talent can it prove to be enough...pbf has been use to cruising to easy wins...can he slay pac that way? I`d say so if pac came in with his hands tied behind his back...but consider the equal in size the heart that pbf hasn't needed in his fights...the warrior in pac...can one really say pbf will jst win...no, and also its faster for a fight to end for a fighter that can stun you...then a boxer that needs 12 to get that win...

this was fun I'm tired now any thoughts people?

Mayweather beats either of the other two. Here's the reason: He does get hit less than Winky, and he is far smarter than the Mosley who faced Winky. He can nullify Winky's jab with footwork and his right hand is superior to Winky's left cross. I think that Mayweather would have a chance though slim fighting Winky as it is, but at the same weight he would win everytime. Same against Pacquaio who just doesn't have enough defense or skill to box with PBF who would use his jab and cross and pick Pacquaio apart.

Between Manny and Winky I would have to say Winky wins this... He has better timing, and IMO Winky was as fast p4p as Pacqiao in terms of handspeed, and still would be fast enough to control Pacquaio with his jab. If Pacquaio had problems with Morales at times then Winky would be way too difficult for him due to vastly superior defense than anything Manny has faced, and far better timing. Everytime Pacman would try to come in that jab would snap his head back.