Thread: Who Do you think won these fights ?

Just post the name of the fighter you think won these fights

Taylor vs Hopkins 1

Taylor vs Hopkins 2

Taylor vs Winky

Taylor vs Spinks

Originally Posted by GAME

Just post the name of the fighter you think won these fights

Taylor vs Hopkins 1

Taylor vs Hopkins 2

Taylor vs Winky

Taylor vs Spinks

Taylor

Don't know haven't seen second one

Winky at first i thought Taylor but after rewatching it alot of Taylors blows were blocked so Winky

Haven't seen this one yet i'll let you know.

Taylor

Hopkins

Taylor

Spinks

taylor
Hopkins
wright (ALL DAY LONG)
taylor

I think Taylor won the first two Hopkins fights and drew with Winky and beat Spinks. Actually it happened how it happened. I thought he could have beat Winky but that was a close fight. But I go with the judges. People saying Spinks won last night is what I am not really understanding. I can see why the other fights you question since they were close, but Spinks fought a good fight to land fast punches, but did not fight to win. All it takes nowadays to win is to survive to the end of the fight and land a few punches in each round? Champions do not come that easy. You have to judge who is landing the effective punches and the better punches. If neither guy is punching much, you have to judge who landed more.. And Taylor was sharper with his counters. Clearly. There shouldn't be a question of who won, just of why Taylor didn't punch much. I just think with Spinks style and speed, Taylor didn't want to make a mistake. Fact is Spinks probably hit harder than it seemed or Taylor would have thrown more punches. But Taylor won clearly.

hopkins
taylor
winky
spinks

Taylor
Taylor
Draw
Taylor

I havn't disagreed with any of the decisions thus far but some were very close. He's been lucky in that every close fight he's had the judges have seen it his way.

But Winky should have beat him. I had him ahead going into the last round but he threw it away by not engaging.

Hopkins started waaaaaaaaaaaaay too late in the first fight. He didn't even get going until round 8 at which point he needed a knockout or at least a couple knockdowns to win.

The second fight he started a couple rounds earlier but Taylor suprosed everyone by winning the last couple rounds.

Winky was his most controversial fight imo, but I felt a draw was fair.

Spinks didn't beat him, although I think an argument could well have been made for him being stripped of his title and purse witheld becuase he sucked so bad.

like I said before, it doesnt matter, Calzaghe will avenge hopkins and Winky...

CALZAGHE IS GOING TO MASSACRE TAYLOR :-)

:-)

hopkins
taylor
winky
spinks

Hopkins
Didn't bother to watch it after the 1st snore-fest
Winky by 2-4 rounds
Neither one of them deserved to win, so I'd call it a draw. But if I had to pick someone it would be Spinks.

hopkins
hopkins
wirght
spinks

Taylor
Taylor
Winky
Taylor

Taylor vs Hopkins 1 Hopkins

Taylor vs Hopkins 2 Taylor

Taylor vs Winky Taylor

Taylor vs Spinks Taylor

Taylor vs Hopkins 1? Hopkins.

Taylor vs Hopkins 2? Taylor.

Taylor vs Winky? Winky.

Taylor vs Spinks? Spinks

I feel Taylor won both fights with Hopkins.

I feel Winky edged out Taylor 7-5, but I'm not complaining because it was an extremely close fight.

And finally, I feel that Taylor deserved the decision against Spinks.