Thread: Who beat Malignaggi better?

Cotto or hatton ?

One guy stopped him the other couldnt. One guy floored him, the other couldnt. Was Cotto was fighting an undfeated prime Malignaggi and Hatton got his leftovers or was Hatton fighting an established champ and Coot got the green version ?

Its no brainer of course Ricky Hatton did, despite all of Paul Malignaggi's injuries against Miguel Cotto. He was always in the fight and even stunned Miguel Cotto a few times, and he won atleast 4 rounds.

Except for the 1st round Paul Malignaggi lost every single round against Ricky Hatton. He was totally outclassed in every aspect and looked on the verge of quitting at the end.

The only reason Hatton didn't get a KD was because Malignaggi managed to grab hold of him on the way down.

Yeah I think Cotto and Hatton kind of put on a different pressure as well.. Hatton fought a really great fight, and kept a lot of pressure on and gave PM no chance at all to get his work happening.. Cotto wasn't as relentless and PM had a bit of freedom to get into his rhythm, but when Cotto landed some big shots, Paulie wasn't in a position to save himself and went down from harder blows...
People on the stream I was watching the fight on were saying Hatton is better than Cotto because Paulie looked better against Cotto than he did Hatton... Hatton was better against Paulie that Cotto was and nullified Paulie's game much better on the night.. But I wouldn't say that makes him any better than Cotto.. Style's make fights as they say...

oh please....

The answer to this question came from Malignaggi's own mouth after the fight.

Originally Posted by TitoFan

oh please....

The answer to this question came from Malignaggi's own mouth after the fight.

Didn't he just say Cotto hurt him more?

First time Hatton landed cleanly Paulie was on queer street. After that he just grabbed hold.

You have to say Hatton. Cotto fight might have been more brutal, but it was a much closer fight. Paulie won 4/5 rounds against Cotto and he stunned him.

Paulie is supposed to be a better fighter now with the world title fights under his belt, but he was outclassed big time last night. He was outboxed, out sped, out fought. The speed that Hatton closed the distance had Paulie hesitating, and Paulie didn't want to throw anything of his own because he was scared of what would come back.

A novice (in comparison) Paulie broke his hand and cheekbone(i think) against Cotto and still made it really competitive. Hatton anhialated him.

Originally Posted by ono

Originally Posted by TitoFan

oh please....

The answer to this question came from Malignaggi's own mouth after the fight.

Didn't he just say Cotto hurt him more?

First time Hatton landed cleanly Paulie was on queer street. After that he just grabbed hold.

You have to say Hatton. Cotto fight might have been more brutal, but it was a much closer fight. Paulie won 4/5 rounds against Cotto and he stunned him.

Paulie is supposed to be a better fighter now with the world title fights under his belt, but he was outclassed big time last night. He was outboxed, out sped, out fought. The speed that Hatton closed the distance had Paulie hesitating, and Paulie didn't want to throw anything of his own because he was scared of what would come back.

A novice (in comparison) Paulie broke his hand and cheekbone(i think) against Cotto and still made it really competitive. Hatton anhialated him.

And what's the point of this useless thread? To imply that Hatton is somehow better than Cotto? Too bad they never met in the ring. That would've settled a lot of moot arguments in the past. Of course, if Hatton would consider going up to 147 to fight DLH, maybe he should have a tune-up first against Cotto (at 147).

I'd have to say Cotto. Ricky won more rounds, but Cotto gave him a worse beating I think. Also, the stoppage has no bearing, because it was a dumb stoppage and IMO Ricky was not going to stop paulie if MCgirt didnt throw the towel in.

The only people who vote for Cotto must be groupies.

Cotto conceeded 4/5 rounds against this chump.

Hatton conceeded one and beat him both on the inside and outside.

Big wow Cotto floored him, it was a flash knockdown anyway. When Hatton landed a jab it looked like Paulie would go down.

Hatton took him to school, Paulie was very much competitive in the Cotto fight.

Easy choice IMO.

I'm not a Cotto or Hatton groupie, but I do think Cotto gave him a greater beating, but this is tied into the fact the Malignaggi chose to engage more in the Cotto fight (although he he did still hold a lot). The stoppage is irrelavant. I almost feel bad for Ricky here though, he gave one of the best performances of his career, he deserved to have someone fight back and put some effort in.

The hatton fight was more one sided .

The cotto fight was more competitive but Paulie took more punishment.

I give the edge to Hatton though.

Hatton took all the rounds except for 1 and schooled paulie.

But Cotto broke his FACE and sent his ass to the hospital.

so Cotto did.

either way both beat the crap outta him so who cares Paulie still lost.

Hatton beat him a lot easier than Cotto

Originally Posted by kingfrnk

Hatton took all the rounds except for 1 and schooled paulie.

But Cotto broke his FACE and sent his ass to the hospital.

so Cotto did.

either way both beat the crap outta him so who cares Paulie still lost.

Cotto beat him better cos he sent him to hospital? This is boxing my friend, Hatton Paulie fight was awy more one sided hense the reason he was pulled out.

Originally Posted by skel1983

Originally Posted by kingfrnk

Hatton took all the rounds except for 1 and schooled paulie.

But Cotto broke his FACE and sent his ass to the hospital.

so Cotto did.

either way both beat the crap outta him so who cares Paulie still lost.

Cotto beat him better cos he sent him to hospital? This is boxing my friend, Hatton Paulie fight was awy more one sided hense the reason he was pulled out.

i know paulie was out scored by Hatton thats why i said he schooled him.

but it depents on how you define BEAT i guess. if u think beat is schooling the shit out of him then its Hatton.

if u look at paulie after the cotto fight and then look at him after the Hatton fight then tell me which paulie looks more fuked up.