Kelly became my favourite fighter in 2007 when he ko'd Zertuche, Miranda and Taylor.
Against Hopkins he was up against someone who was 10 pounds heavier than he was and Pavlik was also suffering from bronchitis. That said, Hopkins exposed some glaring technical deficiencies in Kelly as well as the aforementioned physical ones.
His footwork was nowhere near up to speed, and his basic jab-jab-right hand strategy that worked so well against everyone before Hopkins was made to look basic by Bernard the master tactician. After the fight Bernard made an interesting point that Kelly had the tools to be great but that he was lacking the certain slickness that (in Bernard's words) black fighters possess. I don't like to use race when describing fighters, but Bernard does have a point, even though Hispanic fighters can be slick (JMM) and black fighters can brawl (Miranda).
I think Kelly should perhaps do a Ricky Hatton and team up with a new trainer (like a Floyd Mayweather) who can show him a few new tricks. I don't want to see Kelly (or Hatton for that matter) all of a sudden trying to shoulder roll and shoe shine, but if Kelly's fight against Hopkins showed one thing to me it's that Pavlik (and Jack Lowe) do not know everything about boxing and, in actual fact, are glaringly weak in some areas like footwork, head movement and the general black 'slickness' that Bernard spoke of after the fight.
In saying all that, I believe that Kelly will get back down to 160 and destroy Rubio next time out and will probabbly have too much for Abraham as well if the German has the balls to get in the ring with him.
In response to your question, I don't think Bernard ruined Kelly. He gave him plenty to think about, but I think that will actually (hopefully) make him better in the long run. Don't know if you've read this, but here is a great article by Thomas Hauser of secondsout.com about the Hopkins/Pavlik fight. I posted the link immediately after the fight, but here it is again if you didn't read it:-
Boxing - Columns - Thomas Hauser
Bookmarks