Thread: The Five All Time Worst Boxing Decisions

This article is meant to be contrasted as only opinion, but there is more to it. This writer will explore the tale-of-the-tape, the circumstances and how it went down, who deserved to win, and most importantly, why.

This will only cover modern-era fights, mainly between 1980's until now, because one can simply not find enough material to sift through and cover. Now, for the moment you have been waiting for...

Number 5:
Jose Luis Castillo v... Full Boxing Article here...

Excellent work. Whittaker definitely got the shaft a few times! He was such an athletic specimen, truly a pre-madonna Roy Jones.

I thought ODH just beat Pernell.

Lennox v Holyfield 1 was bad so was MAB v EM 1.

Just an idea, but maybe we could find links for these fights and give our opinions on them after watching them again. They'll be fresh in our minds that way. I know we did something similar in the past. I dunno, flame away.

Does worst ref fight stoppages count? Or is that another thread?

Nice article, props to the author. I agree totally with the Floyd Castillo fight, Castillo worked his arse off in the latter part of the fight only to get robbed I was fuming at that

Originally Posted by Master

I thought ODH just beat Pernell.

Yeh me too, had it even after 11

Seems the list is never ending and always grows unfortunatly,a few that stickave Tiberi vs. James Toney....Omar Weis vs. Antonio Diaz.....Felix Sturm vs. ODH...Fres Oquendo vs. Chris Byrd...Guty Espadas vs. Eric Morales....Wayne McCullough vs. Jose L. Bueno/Victor Rabanales

Originally Posted by Spicoli

Seems the list is never ending and always grows unfortunatly,a few that stickave Tiberi vs. James Toney....Omar Weis vs. Antonio Diaz.....Felix Sturm vs. ODH...Fres Oquendo vs. Chris Byrd...Guty Espadas vs. Eric Morales....Wayne McCullough vs. Jose L. Bueno/Victor Rabanales

Tiberi-Toney worse one in history by far!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was there in AC live and still cannot believe what I saw that night.

Originally Posted by holmcall

Originally Posted by Spicoli

Seems the list is never ending and always grows unfortunatly,a few that stickave Tiberi vs. James Toney....Omar Weis vs. Antonio Diaz.....Felix Sturm vs. ODH...Fres Oquendo vs. Chris Byrd...Guty Espadas vs. Eric Morales....Wayne McCullough vs. Jose L. Bueno/Victor Rabanales

Tiberi-Toney worse one in history by far!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was there in AC live and still cannot believe what I saw that night.

Was pretty bad indeed.Was it Dierdorf?I thought he was going to stroke out right then and there.Strange why Tiberi never fought again??

Dave had his feelings hurt and wanted to be near Christ he said.

Originally Posted by boozeboxer

Dave had his feelings hurt and wanted to be near Christ he said.

Yeah, that pretty well sums it up. He got disgusted and just walked away. He is a deeply religious bloke and now has a nephew fighting who is 8-0. He also has a good buisness and is doing very well for himself. Nice guy.

Originally Posted by Spicoli

Originally Posted by holmcall

Originally Posted by Spicoli

Seems the list is never ending and always grows unfortunatly,a few that stickave Tiberi vs. James Toney....Omar Weis vs. Antonio Diaz.....Felix Sturm vs. ODH...Fres Oquendo vs. Chris Byrd...Guty Espadas vs. Eric Morales....Wayne McCullough vs. Jose L. Bueno/Victor Rabanales

Tiberi-Toney worse one in history by far!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I was there in AC live and still cannot believe what I saw that night.

Was pretty bad indeed.Was it Dierdorf?I thought he was going to stroke out right then and there.Strange why Tiberi never fought again??

Yep, it was Dierdorf. A hush fell across Trumps as the people just stood their in disbelief. Toney, who was hanging across the rops totally exhausted, showed shock, albeit pleasant, when the decision was announced. Then, the croed started yelling "bullshit bullshit" and that went on for quite some time.