Thread: pacquiao is still p4p #1

ring mag's top 5 p4p as of may 4, 2010

1. pacquiao (same)
2. floyd (same)
3. jmm (up 1 notch)
4. donaire (up 1 notch)
5. mosley (down 2 notches)

pacquiao is still recognized as p4p #1 today.

big shakeup in 6th to 10th slots with the entry of martinez and pongsaklek.

6. dawson (up 2 notches)
7. williams (up 2 notches)
8. martinez (new entry)
9. pongsaklek (new entry)
10. caballero (same)

Originally Posted by toe2toe

ring mag's top 5 p4p as of may 4, 2010

1. pacquiao (same)
2. floyd (same)
3. jmm (up 1 notch)
4. donaire (up 1 notch)
5. mosley (down 2 notches)

pacquiao is still recognized as p4p #1 today.

No way mosely in the top ten BEFORE the fight. He only beat margocheater...who esle..mayorga vargas..? lost to Cotto and winky.

Nonito will be out of the top twenty after vic gets finished with him...

Originally Posted by mickel

Originally Posted by toe2toe

ring mag's top 5 p4p as of may 4, 2010

1. pacquiao (same)
2. floyd (same)
3. jmm (up 1 notch)
4. donaire (up 1 notch)
5. mosley (down 2 notches)

pacquiao is still recognized as p4p #1 today.

No way mosely in the top ten BEFORE the fight. He only beat margocheater...who esle..mayorga vargas..? lost to Cotto and winky.

Nonito will be out of the top twenty after vic gets finished with him...

possible but what happens to donaire's rating if he defeats/ko darchinyan again?

Nice to see Martinez up there. Believe he should be higher then Mosley in current rankings.

ring mag's top 10 p4p as of may 4, 2010

1. pacquiao (same)
2. floyd (same)
3. jmm (up 1 notch)
4. donaire (up 1 notch)
5. mosley (down 2 notches)
6. dawson (up 2 notches)
7. williams (up 2 notches)
8. martinez (new entry)
9. pongsaklek (new entry)
10. caballero (same)

So does that mean Mayweather just fought the number 2 p4p fighter in the world and the number 3 p4p fighter in the world in his last 2 fights?

I disagree, Floyd is number 1 after Saturdays performance. How do you keep someone like that off the top after Saturday?

I think GoldenBoy have kept him off the top to piss him off and possibly use another small angle to goad him into fighting Pac.

Originally Posted by Althugz

I disagree, Floyd is number 1 after Saturdays performance. How do you keep someone like that off the top after Saturday?

I think GoldenBoy have kept him off the top to piss him off and possibly use another small angle to goad him into fighting Pac.

ring mag's ranking committee still considers pacquiao as p4p #1.

Originally Posted by Majesty

So does that mean Mayweather just fought the number 2 p4p fighter in the world and the number 3 p4p fighter in the world in his last 2 fights?

yes and floyd will be fighting the p4p #1 if he fights pacquiao next.

Good to see The Ring agree with me. Until Floyd fights and beats Pacquiao, he's staying number 2 in my eyes.

Originally Posted by Althugz

I disagree, Floyd is number 1 after Saturdays performance. How do you keep someone like that off the top after Saturday?

he hasnt fought the #1 boxer yet.

Originally Posted by Althugz

I disagree, Floyd is number 1 after Saturdays performance. How do you keep someone like that off the top after Saturday?

Agree with Althugz here. Did Pacquiao beat the #1 guy to become p4p #1? Mayweather beat two top ten guys in his last two fight althought one of them was a lightweight.

Althugz, maybe the logic was that to be dethroned as #1, you either lose or you retire; oitherwise, you retain the ranking?

Originally Posted by Rantcatrat;873290
[I

Althugz[/I], maybe the logic was that to be dethroned as #1, you either lose or you retire; oitherwise, you retain the ranking?

if thats not how it works then pbf will hold the #1 slot till he dies? he retired undefeated.

Originally Posted by mnmc10

Originally Posted by Althugz

I disagree, Floyd is number 1 after Saturdays performance. How do you keep someone like that off the top after Saturday?

he hasnt fought the #1 boxer yet.

Pacquaio never beat Floyd when he was p4p number 1 either to claim the spot in the first place.

Rantcatrat, who knows what the logic is when judging p4p rankings lol - Everyone has their own way of measuring p4p. Most peoples Top 10 beneath the first 2 are night and day apart