Having had a few hours to get used to it tonight, I have decided that I like it a lot. I miss my favourite fighters (Toney and Barrera), but have been playing as Calzaghe and have been doing okay. I started a new career and having realised what XP is about have realised that it isn't that tough. Before I was simply never upgrading my skills. As usual I have taken on the qualities of my fighter and have been having a riot. I haven't been getting many KO's, but I don't really care as I enjoy boxing the pants off people. That has always been my thing.
I haven't attempted the story mode yet as I am saving that for my post Calzaghe career when I have fully refined my skills, but hopefully that will be just as fun.
All in all I think EA have done well. It's a really fun game.
Bookmarks