Thread: boxing legend pd for pd does everyone agree

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

I'm confused...I thought that you didn't like Lewis?

I striked off who I don't agree with on your list.

Wladimer klitoris has no chin!

Well if it's actually a ranking of all time p4p top 10, that's a bad list. Only one or 2 I could see being top 10 whatsoever, SRR and Ali.

1 muhammad ali - skill/weight not sure if ali had the all time highest ratio but he does belong on the list
2 wladimir klitschko - number 2? the top 10 even? come on now "suspect" chin overwhelming size advantage and cant even stay undefeated in a division of bums.
3 joe louis - solid entry for heavyweight but not sure if hes p4p
4 sugar ray robinson- guaranteed lock
5 rocky marciano - he wasn't the most skilled boxer and i think thats one of the determining factors of p4p ratings but he did do well despite his size not sure if hes top 10 tho
6 Jack dempsey- solid heavy entry but again not sure if he was p4p
7 evander holyfield- i think he belongs high up on the list
8 larry homes- good heavy but again not sure about top 10 p4p
9 floyd mayweather- hes a high ranking guy for sure
10 lennox lewis- avenged both his losses and the losses in the first place could be considered freak occurances but he was really big and im not sure hes top p4p material.

I don't Robinson is rated too high

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

Larry Holmes is my favourite hw ever but even i don't think he is top 10 he would of been if he would of got decision against Spinks like he deserved but he didn't so he is round about 15 i hope your joking having Wladimir top 2 and Holyfield should never make top ten list.

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

Naerly all Heavyweights

Originally Posted by BIG H

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

Naerly all Heavyweights

He is a troll i had a look at some of his earlier posts and he come out with this intelligent answer =


The greatest boxer pound for pound is wladimir klitschko

im suprised with a screen name like jamestoney he didnt put lights out himself on the list seeing that Wlad is on it? lol

Originally Posted by TheBESTP4P

im suprised with a screen name like jamestoney he didnt put lights out himself on the list seeing that Wlad is on it? lol

And also he done exact same list last year as well so he is just trying to get rise out of people i would move this pointless topic

wtf hes been here a whole year and he only has 30posts?
damn is he mentally challenged or something?

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

I crossed out the ones I disagree with and the rest I can live with.
No Duran

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

I crossed out the ones I disagree with and the rest I can live with.
No Duran

Actually Holmes is more deserving to be in that list than Dempsey he isn't even top 20 on my list.

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

Originally Posted by jamestoney

1 muhhammad ali
2 wladimir klitschko
3 joe louis
4 sugar ray robinson
5 rocky marcian
6 Jack dempsey
7 evander holyfield
8 larry homes
9 floyd mayweather
10 lennox lewis

I crossed out the ones I disagree with and the rest I can live with.
No Duran

hey bro speaking of DURAN when i was clubbin in 808 the DJ was all repeating the part of the Jay-Z song i believe its a guest spot on Missy's One Minute Man when Jay-Z is all like: "LIKE ROBERTO DURAN........ NO MAS" ahahhaha