Thread: Does any version of Marquez beat Floyd?

JMM was a lightweight when Floyd fought him. Well, what if they fought later, when Marquez adjusted to WW?

Seriously? It was about as definitive a stylistic shut out as there is, of course not. Marquez never really adjusted to WW imo, every single decent opponent he fought above 130 gave him hell, when he was a lot better than most of them.

Jmm looked better at welterweight after the Floyd fight but he was not good enough to beat Bradley and was getting busted up by Manny so no.

Jmm was knocked down at lightweight before he beat Katasidis whereas Floyd struggled with Castillo but he did not have the same style as Marquez.

Maybe at super feather and feather weight he stood a better chance against Floyd.

Nope a fast counter puncher will beat a slow counter puncher and Floyd is too damn good against Marquez at any weight.

No

Marquez at feather was much deeper and sharp than the chunky Welter he will end at. While he needed to unofficially beat Manny 3 times to claim 1, Floyd was always steps ahead with ring control and speed forcing Marquez to play aggressor. The one or two divisions heavier didn't hurt either.

The fight would have been just as one sided at 130 though, being realistic. I think Floyd could have stopped JMM if he had gone for it.

Originally Posted by p4pking

The fight would have been just as one sided at 130 though, being realistic. I think Floyd could have stopped JMM if he had gone for it.

JMM has never been stopped and I do not think Floyd had the power to do it even at the lower weight.

No way. Floyd was too big, too fast, and too skilled to lose to JMM. I only see significantly larger boxers, or extremely durable/rugged/conditioned fighters beating Floyd. Guys like Leonard and Hearns who were great boxers and much larger than Floyd, or Roberto Duran/Henry Armstrong/Aaron Pryor types who would maul Floyd were the only types I see beating him. Even then, those guys couldn't afford an off night or lapse in focus or Floyd would beat them. I don't like the guy at all, but he was a fantastic talent and fighter.

Originally Posted by Master

Originally Posted by p4pking

The fight would have been just as one sided at 130 though, being realistic. I think Floyd could have stopped JMM if he had gone for it.

JMM has never been stopped and I do not think Floyd had the power to do it even at the lower weight.

He has also never been totally shut down by anyone else. At 130 it would have been more one sided if anything imo, and MArquez would have never gotten more than one try because nobody would need to see it again.

Originally Posted by VG_Addict

JMM was a lightweight when Floyd fought him. Well, what if they fought later, when Marquez adjusted to WW?

Look, many times hypotheticals just won’t work and this is one of them. Marquez would have had a better chance against Floyd at 130/135 then any time that followed. Floyd took more chances back then but they could have never met at that weight.

It’s still a boring fight with Marquez getting nickel and dimed to death. Floyd is simply better at all of the things that make Marquez a great fighter and he's bigger and faster at any weight.

Marquez was/is a completely different fighter since the Manny obsession. He fights more like Lamotta. The entire gains in weight were in prep for one man and landing that one punch. Imo he actually became a little one dimensional. I think Floyd would have an easier time with the welter version of Marquez then he did against the flabby one.