Thread: Keith Thurman- A waste of talent, or he never had it to be the top guy?

What are your thoughts on Keith Thurman? He got his ass kicked by Manny and kinda retired after that. Kinda young to have retired, too. Was he a waste of talent or was he all talk and never had it in him to be the top guy?

I loved the way they made the Danny Garcia fight for him. That was a defining fight for both of them. Arguably, it was the Spence v Crawford before Spence v Crawford. It was the fight to make despite promoters bungling the promotions and mismanaging the fight hype.

But, what do you guys have to say about Thurman? Is he retired now?

I was a big fan of Thurman and really thought he was going to beat Spence and prove he was the best at weight after he beat Porter and Garcia.

Then he stalled for whatever reason injuries or not getting the big fights. I think he sold his 0 when he faced Manny Pac.

Thurman is making a comeback against an Australia against Brock Jarvis in March. Thurman is the underdog and will lose. He is too old now.

Originally Posted by Master

Thurman is making a comeback against an Australia against Brock Jarvis in March. Thurman is the underdog and will lose. He is too old now.

have you seen much of brock? keith is old but he's a live dog here. it's a good match up for the promoters because if brock wins they can use the win to build him back up, if keith wins they can use it to build a fight with timmy

Originally Posted by TIC

Originally Posted by Master

Thurman is making a comeback against an Australia against Brock Jarvis in March. Thurman is the underdog and will lose. He is too old now.

have you seen much of brock? keith is old but he's a live dog here. it's a good match up for the promoters because if brock wins they can use the win to build him back up, if keith wins they can use it to build a fight with timmy

Actually I have not seen Jarvis fight but assumed he was the favourite and bringing in the old champ to beat up at his place.

He was a OK Boxer, but Thurman was overhyped and had way too high an opinion of himself. When the time came to dare to be great he wasn’t up to it.