Some people seem to think he's not done, that he's a viable opponent for any good or elite fighter.

Just wondering why? Write off the second Tarver fight for discussions sake, it was a good punch that he didn't see, but I can't just erase the memory of the Johnson beatdown and the third Tarver non performance where he just solely tried to make it 12 rounds.

He's just way past it IMO. Calzaghe looked sloppy tonight but I still think putting Roy in with him would be a bad idea, not even so much because of Calzaghe but because of the type of fighter Jones is these days.

Hulk get mad at this thread, and throw things against wall, but that's not really the point, its just a discussion, why do you think he's still a viable contender? Who do you think he could beat?