I have always been curious on this. Since people never seem to agree on who the best fighter is and pound for pound list while have basically the same fighters on it tend to vary in the order they are placed. I was just wondering on how the different members here judge a fighter and his ability or should I say what do they favor.

Here is an example of what I mean- We will pretend there are 2 fighters who reside in the same weight class both have the exact same record of 30-0, both men have won titles in the exact same 2 seperate weight classes ( lets say at Junior Welterweight and Welterweight). Each man has the exact same opponents on their resume since winning their titles.

Fighter A is a boxer/puncher that has 26 KO's out of the 30 wins on his resume. While he has never been close to being stopped he has been down 4 or 5 times in his career.

Fighter B is a defensive fighter with only 10 KO's on his resume but all his other wins came by way of UD, he is very slick and his chin is solid as steele and he has not ever come close to even being rocked.

Which fighter would you be the bigger fan of or consider the better of the two? They have the same resume and same credential's one has the better chin the other more power. Which fighter just by reading the scenario would you sway towards? The fighter with good skill and KO power or the top notch defensive fighter who has a rock solid chin?