You guys asked for it, now you guys have it. A poster (Pac fan boy) said in the Pernell Whittaker thread comparing his accomplishments to Pacmans was that Pernell Whittaker was like Roy Jones Jr. that never lived up to his abilities while Pacman is or going to lived up to Sugar Ray Robinson or beginning to lived up to SRR.

Since a Pacman fan uttered Pacquiao and SRR in the same sentence we now come to this discussion. Lets have it. Who would win in a welterweight match if both were in their prime?

Pacman would be a welterweight in Sugar Ray Robinson's day. Since they had same day weigh ins at Robinson's time and Pacman fought Hatton at 148 on fight night, he would need to drop only a pound to make the welterweight limit and just go into the ring at 147. Both would fight at 147 on fight night. So it's a fair match weight wise. And since we are going by SRR time period for weigh ins, I'll be nice and instead go by the modern period of only the maximum 12 rounds instead of 15.

So who wins in the mythical matchup? (BTW, if Pac fans have started to compared Pac's resume to Sugar Ray, it would be a matter of time before they speculate who would win in a mythical matchup. So they brought it upon themselves that this thread was made.)