Thread: Where do u place Morales Hamed Pacquiao Marquez barrera from each other?

From these 5 specifically who do u have in what Order ?

Pacquiao 1st, Hamed Last, the middle is a good debate.

I actually have Morales higher than manny, i felt his opponents were tougher in his prime than compared to pac and has a MUCH Stronger resume than manny who i felt he fought big names but who were on a down period, even the weight class stuff im more impressed with Eriks Four overall, he always fought the younger guys which i give the oldman credit for..

i dont know if i have Barrera ahead of Marquez

Marquez
Pacquiao
Barrera
Morales
Hamed


with the last two being interchangeable

Originally Posted by Julius Rain

Pacquiao 1st, Hamed Last, the middle is a good debate.

I agree. With Pacquiao's record and accomplishments it's hard to place him anywhere but the top. IMO

Pac
Marquez
Barrera & Morales (cannot be spilt!! If ever there were 2 even fighters it's these 2)
HAMED

Pacquiao
Marquez
Morales
Barrera
Hamed

After Morales having success in a comeback I can't have Barrera above him. Erik was badly robbed in the Diaz fight too. Should have been a 5 weight world champ.

Naz
Marquez
Pac
Barrera
Morales

Naz is clearly no.1 - he's the only one that unified a division by beating every other "world" champ in his weightclass. His only "loss" was due to a shocking inept display of officiating (Barrera should have been disqualified in the 12th round for violent conduct). And he was never knocked out (only Marquez can match him on this, however, he's been on the floor more than Naz).

It's not even close. Fact.

Originally Posted by Fenster

Naz
Marquez
Pac
Barrera
Morales

Naz is clearly no.1 - he's the only one that unified a division by beating every other "world" champ in his weightclass. His only "loss" was due to a shocking inept display of officiating (Barrera should have been disqualified in the 12th round for violent conduct). And he was never knocked out (only Marquez can match him on this, however, he's been on the floor more than Naz).

It's not even close. Fact.

Got to admire the dedication to the cause lol.

Originally Posted by Fenster

Naz
Marquez
Pac
Barrera
Morales

Naz is clearly no.1 - he's the only one that unified a division by beating every other "world" champ in his weightclass. His only "loss" was due to a shocking inept display of officiating (Barrera should have been disqualified in the 12th round for violent conduct). And he was never knocked out (only Marquez can match him on this, however, he's been on the floor more than Naz).

It's not even close. Fact.

When you put it like that how could one argue?

Pac-Marquez (Pac's record is better, I think Marquez is the better fighter all round)
MAB
Morales
Hamed

It's hard to know where to really place Hamed (at the bottom, or not even on the list! Which one? ), he only faced one of the other guys on the list.

I dunno, he missed all but one of his main rivals and the one who he did fight schooled him stupid. That's the only real grounds for comparison that we've got. Anything else is speculation.

We can give credit for unifying a division, but how much depends on whether you place more value on alphabet titles - or the level of talent holding them.

Maybe if he'd been able to gain 2lbs to take Mayweather's offer of 128lb then we'd have more relevant fights for comparison. I know he is the type of guy who struggles to put weight on, but surely his ungodly heavyweight power should have made 2lbs nothing.

Juan Manuel Marquez
Erik Morales
Manny Pacquiao
Marco Antonio Barrera
Kennedy McKinney
Naseem Hamed

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Juan Manuel Marquez
Erik Morales
Manny Pacquiao
Marco Antonio Barrera
Kennedy McKinney
Naseem Hamed

I love the way VD keeps bias out of the equation with his decision making.

OFFICIAL RESULTS ON NASEEM HAMED:

So far our distinguished voters have seen it this way on Hamed, from a list with 5 fighters:


5th place: 6 voters

1st place: 1 voter

Notes:

1. One voter didn't even mention Hamed, which could be interpreted as a vote for 5th place.
2. One voter placed Hamed 6th, even adding a name to the list and further dropping Hamed.


The results speak for themselves, gentlemen.








Yes......... I'm afraid we're all wrong.

1. Barrera
2. Morales
3. Pacquiao
4. Marquez
5. Hamed