Thread: Rigo and Donaire vs P4P rankings

So where do you rank them now. I think both just have to be in the top 10. I have rigo at 5 or 6 and Donaire at 8 .

your views?

(both should be ahead of Broner )

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

I agree with you. Each man has done more in the ring than Broner has. Donaire shouldn't fall out of the top 10 just due to one loss to another super talent in Guillermo Rigondeaux.

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

Originally Posted by gest12645

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

I said that Rigo would win, but Donaire didn't seem up for it.

But I refuse to say a boxer with 12 fights should be higher than Broner who has more than double his fights at 10 years younger!

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

I said that Rigo would win, but Donaire didn't seem up for it.

But I refuse to say a boxer with 12 fights should be higher than Broner who has more than double his fights at 10 years younger!

Chavez Jr. is a young fella and has more fights than both so shouldn't he be higher ?

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

I said that Rigo would win, but Donaire didn't seem up for it.

But I refuse to say a boxer with 12 fights should be higher than Broner who has more than double his fights at 10 years younger!

Chavez Jr. is a young fella and has more fights than both so shouldn't he be higher ?

Chavez is in my top 10. Klitschko and Guererro are not.

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

I said that Rigo would win, but Donaire didn't seem up for it.

But I refuse to say a boxer with 12 fights should be higher than Broner who has more than double his fights at 10 years younger!

I see your reasoning.
For 1- Rigo has had an amazing amatuer career that somewhat ups his pro career
for 2 - broner has never fought a guy as good as Donaire
for 3 - Broner should have lost to Ponce
for 4- Rigo looks much more skilled than Broner
for 5- put Rigo at LWW and Broner at LWW - Rigo would win no doubt

I tend to agree. Donaire around 10 and Rigo around 5 (despite having just 12 pro fights).

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by Hulk

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

Originally Posted by Vendettos

Originally Posted by gest12645

so many views and no response? Come on boxing fans

Rigo had a good fight, but if its fought twice more, I think Donaire takes them both.

Rigon isn't top 10, he only has 12 fights, that's 2 early. He has been fast tracked though.

Still saying Nonito is top 5.

Come on man, Rigo dominated Donaire , and there wasn't anything that showed that there would be a different result in a rematch. How can a dominated Donaire be higher than Rigo.? My point - both are elite fighters. Rigo is amazing , and Donaire is great.

I said that Rigo would win, but Donaire didn't seem up for it.

But I refuse to say a boxer with 12 fights should be higher than Broner who has more than double his fights at 10 years younger!

Chavez Jr. is a young fella and has more fights than both so shouldn't he be higher ?

Chavez is in my top 10. Klitschko and Guererro are not.

How the fuck is Chavez in your top 10. P4P is suppose to neglect weight and just account for skill. Chavez refuses to fight anyone near his size. Nowhere near a p4p fighter.

My top 10 would be

Mayweather
Martinez
JMM
Ward
Broner
Rigo
Wlad
Matthysse
Mikey Garcia
GGG

I think Donaire was found out and can no longer be in the top 10. Pac been too inactive and lost last 2 to stay in top 10

I think for sure it enters Rigo into the boxing consciousness, but we can't put him top 10 p4p on just ONE win IMO. But with another couple of good wins, he definitely does enter into the discussion

Donaire is still in my top ten, Boxing fans seem to be far too fickle and then they complain why the best never seem to fight each other. Well lo and behold in the mirror and there's your problem. Rigo beat one great boxer I want to see him beat Mares too before I put him in top 10 p4p and this is coming from someone who bet on Rigo to win the fight.

#1 Ward... he's fought and beaten evry majior fighter in his weight class and domianted Dawson...
#2 JMM... his KO over Pac had alot of weight. He did something no one could do.
#3 Mayweather... Too inactive drops him .
#4 Wlad Klitsko... over 10 title defences in a row... litterally cleaned out the div.
#5 Martinez... lack of comp lately... still, he's a solid p4p'er.
#6 Froch... His convincing KO over Bute... this guys a stud,,rematch with Kessler should b a barn burner..Froch could win it.
#7 Manny Pac... still the most dangerous man in boxing.
#8 Vitali needs to fight more..too much inactivity... but no one can beat him.
#9 Danny Garcia... Devastating Ko's over Khan and Morales... undefeated.
#10 Mikey Garcia... i called this guy a stud 2 years ago... has the talent to clean out div.