Our work is done for the month. Saddo's Official P4P List as of April, 2007

Check the link & discuss here...the list is pretty much done courtesy of your own votes.

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxing_fo...html#msg492316

Cheers & koneecheewah.

Well done WackOff 8)

Already voiced my opinion. :)

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by CutMeMicK

Well done WackOff 8)

Already voiced my opinion. :)

---

:coolclick: Thanks babe.

We'll click right over & check it out.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by wacko3205

Check the link & discuss here...the list is pretty much done courtesy of your own votes.

http://www.saddoboxing.com/boxing_fo...html#msg492316

Cheers & koneecheewah.

---

Agree with most apart from Calzaghe he isnt above anyone on that list
nothing title - nothing division- nothing oponants

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

I think Calzaghe and Taylor are both to high on that list, also Cotto needs to do a little more before consdiered in mine, but hey wacko great work dude!! cc

Agree with the great work on your part, Wacko - I doubt anyone on this site agrees 100%, but like you said: It's got a good beat, and you can dance to it.

:coolclick:

CC#2385 Wacko good list

I know you are not directly responsible for it Wacko, but to the rest of you I am deeply dissapointed in your lack of judgement placing Pacquaio in front of Mayweather. I can't see how somebody with any knowledge of boxing would make such a misguided decision. Mayweather is far better than Pacquaio. I am not saying Pacquaio isn't good, but he isn't on Mayweather's level. Its like having Trinidad ahead of Roy Jones on the p4p list back in the day.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by amat

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

---

How does Mayweather have that spot? By beating Gatti? I think Mayweather has been fighting bums.

He currently runs a record of 38 fights, 36 wins with 32 knockouts, and 3 losses.

#7 Rafael Marquez. typo?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by zzz

He currently runs a record of 38 fights, 36 wins with 32 knockouts, and 3 losses.

#7 Rafael Marquez. typo?

---

RAFA MARQUEZ SHOULD BE TOP 3 EASILY!!! i LOVE Cotto but he should not be that high. I alos think PBF fighting Oscar mean keeps him in first place. Pac-Solis does not cut it at all!

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by amat

STRONGLY disagree with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. If he was 5 months ago that's fine, but he's done nothing to surpass him imo. Mayweather has that spot until he starts fighting bums or loses.

---

So how did Mayweather become number 1 p4p for the last 5 months anyway? By beating Baldomir? I didn't vote for this p4p list. But this list is what most people in the forum thinks. And I'm fine with Pacquiao being ahead of Mayweather. Pacquiao may not be as good as Mayweather skillwise but he deserves the spot IMHO due to his hardwork, excitement and determination inside the ring. Some people might not agree with the list but hey this is a place where we all could agree to disagree :lickish:

P.S. Wacko said there were some who voted twice? That sucks.

Some odd choices on that list...
B-Hop ain't even active imo and forget what he has done,what is he doing at present? He hasn't been active for nearly a year now and if he beats Winky then yeah he warrants it because he'll have been in a FIGHT ;D :-\
Calzaghe should be 9 or 10 just for taking the Manfredo fight alone.
Pacman deserves the number 1 slot too.
I think we need to clarify the way fighters are voted for (gotta be the fighters who are active and currently doing it surely) and how many times people can vote before this P4P list goes down the Khazi.
Great feature Wacko so don't let it start to slide ;)
And where the F*CK is Cotto ???
I'm guessing that new members are not thinking outside the box and simply casting wild and numerous votes for fighters with high profiles and big names and not on who is consistently and currently 'doing it' in the ring.

I take it back,I think Manny deserves to be first UNTIL we know the outcome of the Floyd Oscar fight. I don't think Cotto should be there...yet!