Printable View
Just seeing who people thought won. Thought it was a close one, bit surprised to see it being described as a robbery so much but then again a lot of times on here close fights or slightly bad decisions are seen as robberies.
So who won?
If you thought Herman won, was it just a close fight with a somewhat questionable decision or was it an out and out robbery, a horrible injustice or some shit.
Herman won a close, but clear cut decision, but not only rocking Malinaggi, but countering him all night, and outworking him in the last two rounds.
I could see that, I gave him the last two rounds too.
At the time I thought he might have blown it a bit by not doing much in the 8th after hurting him in the seventh but in the end it really didn't matter since the judges had it so wide.
I will say that Bernstein was a bit up Herman's ass, I don't like Paulie much but there were times where he ignored it when Paulie was doing well but really hyped it up when Herman was doing well.
Not an out right robbery and I think Herman had it all there to be gained.He let up late and paulie literaly rode it out.A Draw and or split I could see.The numbers from judges were assnine.117-111=B.S Ive seen Much worse calls,We all saw it.Paulies on borrowed time and Herman deserves one more crack.
"A Draw and or split I could see"
You had a split for Herman or Paulie?
Well to sound boo-koo cliche ...Either one!Score cards were absurd but it was a very nip and tuck affair.when all is said and done I favor Herman and If not for him easing off late he would have (should have) pulled it out.Quote:
Originally Posted by OumaFan
A draw imo a rematch should be made. I had thoughts that Paullie vs Hatton would be a good fight but no I think Hatton would own Paullies ass. Hatton vs Witter is the fight at light weler right now.
What do you guys say to this
Winner : Hatton vs Witter winner of Herman N (lol) vs Paullie 2
vs
Who wins this tourmanent?
I gave it to Ngoudjo. But that's based more on the fact that I dislike Faglignaggi. If you replace Paulie with DeMarcus Corley or let say Kendall Holt. Than I would said they beat Ngoudjo
Paulie is a LIL BITCH isn't he? Its pretty bad when you like Kendall "Ass Dance" Holt, and DeMarcus " I like's my ladies underwear" Corley better than a guy huh? ;DQuote:
Originally Posted by Violent Demise
I voted Paulie.
I had it 115-113 for Paulie I could def. see someone having Herman edging it out by a round.
What I can't see is people saying it was a robbery. I think people have begun to miss use the words "Great" & "Robbery" a lot lately.
To me a robbery is a fight where there is a clear cut winner by at least 2 maybe 3 rounds and the decision goes the other way.
Huerta-Raymkulov, Navarro-Gainer, Ortiz-Diaz, Santa-Joel etc. etc. etc.
A fight like this one where an arguement could be made that some rounds were even some could go either way does not IMO qualify it or justify it as a robbery.
To be honest i got the impression while i was watching it, that if it was a close fight Paulie would get the nod.Quote:
Originally Posted by OumaFan
I only had Herman winning by 115-113 so to see it going the other way isn't a robbery. I think people are mostly pissed off with the judges scorecards rather than the overall decision.
9 rounds to 3 in Paulie's favour is a disgrace.
It's at the point where judges can no longer by relied upon to determine a winner and a loser in a fight and thats sad.
Right the 117-111 card is absurd but I had no problems with the other 2.Quote:
Originally Posted by ono
I had it a draw and i didnt see the first round either so i dont know who won that.. All i know is i had paulie winning 6 rounds out of rounds 2-12
and to be honest look at all the posts prior to this fight anyway
Most these guys dont like paulie so course they gona say paulie lost and it was a robbery..
It was no robbery..It was close.. but not a robbery..
In fact ALOT like barrera marquez.. scores didnt do the fighters justice but a close fight that could have gone either way but imo paulie did enough
I scored it a draw. And whenever I score a fight a draw, I have no problem with a close decision for victory for either guy.
Paulie was the house fighter, therefore it was no surprise that he won by a close decision. If Ngoudjo had won, that would have been fine too.
Ngoudjo won a close fight. I'm glad plenty of people scored it for Powderpuff though.. proves it could of gone either way (If Herman was the "house" fighter he'd of got it) and wasn't a robbery.