Old Straweight, Junior Flyweight, Flyweight, Super-Flyweight & Bantamweight threads

Does Katsunari Takayama remain in the pool at 108 after his loss to Roman Gonzalez at Straw?

I vote he is removed

Merge all lowest weightclass threads in here

I knew i forgot something last night. Light Flyweight Hernan Marquez just beat Juan Esquer over 12 rounds. Should he get the vacant 9th spot in the division? I say yes. He's undefeated. And Esquer was no push over. He almost beat Ivan Calderon a couple of years ago. I was meaning to vote on this prior to the fight but kept forgetting.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

I knew i forgot something last night. Light Flyweight Hernan Marquez just beat Juan Esquer over 12 rounds. Should he get the vacant 9th spot in the division? I say yes. He's undefeated. And Esquer was no push over. He almost beat Ivan Calderon a couple of years ago. I was meaning to vote on this prior to the fight but kept forgetting.

---

Hey VD, good to have you back aboard!

You need to create a new poll, set it to close in 3 days, leave it open so we can see who has voted & put all the fighters in the pool at 108 & those you think worth of nomination as options to vote on. You also need to include the option to leave the position vacant

For the record Esquer put a lot of pressure on Calderon but was nowhere near beating Calderon!!!

If you like I can put the poll up for you?

Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?

Munetsugu Kayo
Adrian Hernandez
Brahim Asloum
Edren Dapudong
Rodel Mayol
Herman Marquez

Should Juanito Rubillar be removed from the pool at 108 after being stopped by Giovanni Segura?

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Galaxy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

I knew i forgot something last night. Light Flyweight Hernan Marquez just beat Juan Esquer over 12 rounds. Should he get the vacant 9th spot in the division? I say yes. He's undefeated. And Esquer was no push over. He almost beat Ivan Calderon a couple of years ago. I was meaning to vote on this prior to the fight but kept forgetting.

---

Hey VD, good to have you back aboard!

You need to create a new poll, set it to close in 3 days, leave it open so we can see who has voted & put all the fighters in the pool at 108 & those you think worth of nomination as options to vote on. You also need to include the option to leave the position vacant

For the record Esquer put a lot of pressure on Calderon but was nowhere near beating Calderon!!!

If you like I can put the poll up for you?

---

Yeah go ahead. Thanks. And I only had Esquer losing by a point or two.

Who fills the #10 spot at Strawweight?

Manuel Vargas
Denver Cuello
Ronald Barrera
Luis Alberto Rios

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Galaxy

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

I knew i forgot something last night. Light Flyweight Hernan Marquez just beat Juan Esquer over 12 rounds. Should he get the vacant 9th spot in the division? I say yes. He's undefeated. And Esquer was no push over. He almost beat Ivan Calderon a couple of years ago. I was meaning to vote on this prior to the fight but kept forgetting.

---

Hey VD, good to have you back aboard!

You need to create a new poll, set it to close in 3 days, leave it open so we can see who has voted & put all the fighters in the pool at 108 & those you think worth of nomination as options to vote on. You also need to include the option to leave the position vacant

For the record Esquer put a lot of pressure on Calderon but was nowhere near beating Calderon!!!

If you like I can put the poll up for you?

---

Yeah go ahead. Thanks. And I only had Esquer losing by a point or two.

---

Done mate, just pop in there & add your vote.

Really? I had it wider

Herman Marquez should fill it. If the 9th spot gets filled than I can live with Mayol being placed at 10th. But I don't agree with him getting the 9th spot based on a draw

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Violent Demise

Herman Marquez should fill it. If the 9th spot gets filled than I can live with Mayol being placed at 10th. But I don't agree with him getting the 9th spot based on a draw

---

That's what the votes for. Remember as Manager your vote is worth 2 points, so Marquez is still technically ahead at this point.

Your basing Marquez' rank on beating Esquer & being undefeated, I also think he is an excellent prospect, but Calderon beat Esquer back in '07 & he'd lost 3 of his last 6 coming into the Marquez fight. Mayol fought to a six round draw with the #1 guy in our rankings & although it ended in only 6 rounds I feel it deserves some recognition.

My opinion is he didn't lose to our #1 guy & was nominated after the Calderon fight for ranking (receiving votes), so I feel he deserves to be nominated again...

He's a tough ol' durable fighter, but he looked less than relevant in that fight.

His career is over having lost all his bids for the title

Tyson has the ability to become a world champion and he has shown great chin too. Esquer has connected with great punches but he manages to withstand the relentless Esquer and won.

The Poll has now closed. The results are as follows:

Rubillar is removed from the pool by a vote of 6 points to 0