Surprise! Another bad scorecard

how would a judge ever have martiroysen beating andrade? even the scorecard that had andrade winning by only 1 point was bad. i feel like there have been so many terrible scorecards in the last few years that judges should just start getting fired for obviously not being able to judge. there is no way you could watch the fight and have martiroysen winning. i had him winning 2 rounds and the one he was losing but got a KD. i could see the most giving him would be 4 rounds. the judge have him the first 4 rounds. that shows how bad it was because the 2nd round was so clearly andrade that you would have to be blind to not give him the round.

anyways, im so tired of these bad scorecards.

Your sarcasm is well received. The judge should be questioned and forced to re-watch the fight with a panel of more experienced judges.

Normally, I don't care about the score cards as long as the right fighter wins, but the awful judging seems to be increasing.

You always want your judges to be free to call it the way they see it, but they have to meet a basic standard. It seems like more and more judges are missing the basic training to judge a fight.

Martirosyan was less active, but landed the cleaner, harder punches. Andrade was busier with his jab.

I scored it 114-113 for Andrade, 7 rounds to 5 plus the knockdown.

I thought Max Kellerman's commentary was extremely biased in favor of Andrade, and perhaps was misleading viewers. The wide 117-110 score for Andrade was just as bad as the 115-112 for Martirosyan.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Freedom

Martirosyan was less active, but landed the cleaner, harder punches. Andrade was busier with his jab.

I scored it 114-113 for Andrade, 7 rounds to 5 plus the knockdown.

I thought Max Kellerman's commentary was extremely biased in favor of Andrade, and perhaps was misleading viewers. The wide 117-110 score for Andrade was just as bad as the 115-112 for Martirosyan.

---

Good point on equal gap for Andrade. I had him winning but you can see a scenario watching that fight where Andrade was waiting way too much, watching and often almost one handed and his footwork was crossed and bad. Vanes was sloppy but attempting to set a pace and landing his share. If it was "just Martirosyan" as Max repeated and a showcase to stake claim for young Andrade who was dropping Canelo and Mayweathers name prior...he'll next to do more next time around. Much more.

In light of recent travesties one would thing judges would be extra judicious right now but apparently caution to the wind is the rule.

Atleast the judging for championship fights should be the exclusive realm of tested and experienced judges and not trial horses. Same with referees!

are people seriously thinking that it was mex kellerman that swayed everybody to think that andrade won the fight easily? haha.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

are people seriously thinking that it was mex kellerman that swayed everybody to think that andrade won the fight easily? haha.

---

I'm laughing too, but there are plenty of fans who believe everything the broadcast crew say.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

are people seriously thinking that it was mex kellerman that swayed everybody to think that andrade won the fight easily? haha.

---

Nah, it's just that not everyone saw it a 117-111 result Pointing out a guy heavily pushing a guy doesn't translate to him influencing even minded fans, at least it shouldn't and more importantly the judges. It is hbo after all, home of the King if distortion himself Jim Lampley.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Spicoli

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by powerpuncher

are people seriously thinking that it was mex kellerman that swayed everybody to think that andrade won the fight easily? haha.

---

Nah, it's just that not everyone saw it a 117-111 result Pointing out a guy heavily pushing a guy doesn't translate to him influencing even minded fans, at least it shouldn't and more importantly the judges. It is hbo after all, home of the King if distortion himself Jim Lampley.

---

im not saying you have to have it that wide, but if you even think that you could give the fight to martyrosan then you are blind.

There's no way anyone could score that fight for Martirosyan & keep a straight face

Judge needs to be disciplined