Kevin Mitchell earns the #10 ranking by efeating Breidis Prescott by a vote of 6 - 0
Printable View
Kevin Mitchell earns the #10 ranking by efeating Breidis Prescott by a vote of 6 - 0
Rafal Jackiewics enters the pool by a vote of 3 - 0
Delvin Rodriguez remains in the pool by a vote of 4 - 0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...lterweight.jpg
How far should Juan Diaz (currently #5 & 2nd at 135) drop after losing to 6th rated Paulie Malignaggi? 1-3 spots?
Juan Diaz
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...tereweight.jpg
How far should Isaac Hlatswayo (currently #7) drop after being dropped in the 2nd & then stopped in the 3rd by Jan Zaveck?
Isaac Hlatshwayo
1 spot to 8th
2 spots to 9th
3 spots to 10th
Straight to the pool
Man Diaz is a warrior but honestly...if the pool was an option I might go for it.I think he's all but done.3 for me
Juan Diaz drops 3 spots by a vote of 5 - 1
Isaac Hlatswayo drops 3 spots by a vote of 5 - 0
Should Lamont Peterson remain in the pool at 140 after losing to Timothy Bradley (currently #2)?
Lamont Peterson
I'm going to be away on holiday during the actual voting period, so I wanted to do mine now, if it's successful, you can either implement it now or do it at the start of January.
Anyway, my vote is that Floyd Mayweather moves above Jan Zaveck. I just can't see Zaveck being a Top 7 fighter in a division this good. His win said more to me about the weaknesses in Hlatshwayo than about how good Zaveck is & I think Mayweather being below him doesn't reflect well on our rankings.
I do think we should do something where someone can jump up 1 or 2 places based on quality, as I think the same should apply to Paul Williams in the Middleweight division, where he is certainly one of the Top 3 fighters in the division.
At least Hlatswayo was fighting welterweights!
But I see where your coming from & I'm really not too fussed. Should Mayweather beat Pacquiao he will sky rocket straight to 2nd anyway.
But for now I agree that Zaveck should be demoted below Floyd
Apart from the Marquez fight, Mayweather had fought fighters who all had credentials at Welterweight. I mean I see your point & it's why I wouldn't have had him ranked above either Mosley or Cotto when he re-entered the rankings, but he has got some merit at the weight. Let's face it we had Pacquiao ranked when he had yet to fight a welterweight (Oscar not being one in the same way Marquez wasn't).Quote:
Originally Posted by Galaxy
Jan Zaveck will be demoted below Mayweather by a vote of 3 - 1
Lamont Peterson remains in the pool by a vote of 5 - 0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...tereweight.jpg
Should Shane Mosley (currently #1) vs Andre Berto (currently #4) be for our championship?
Shane Mosley
Andre Berto