Printable View
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
Does David Tua vs Friday Ahunanya qualify for the vacant 10th ranking or pool entry or is it not worthy of either? Tua has not lost since 2001, he has had 13 fights since that loss to Chris Byrd going 12-0-1 (10). Ahunanya's last to fights have been victories over previously undefeated opposition in Alonzo Butler & Shane Cameron.
David Tua - Boxer
Friday Ahunanya - Boxer
I don't think it's worthy of the #10 spot, it might as well be worthy of the pool, but the winner of Thompson/Estrada is more worthy of #10 IMO.
I guess I don't mind it being for pool entry.
I rate Tua ahead of both Thompson & Estrada, especially since Estrada is coming of a loss. Pool entry is fair thoughQuote:
Originally Posted by killersheep
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
After getting stopped in the 1st round by Chris Henry should Hugo Garay drop from the pool?
Should Garay drop from the pool after his 1st round stoppage loss to Chris Henry?
Yes, drops from pool (5 votes) : Cleon, Galaxy, Killersheep, markb018 (+1)
No, stays in pool (2 votes) : JazMerkin, Violent Demise
Garay drops from the pool by a vote of 5-2
What does the winner of David Tua vs. Friday Ahunanya qualify for?
Vacant #10 spot (2 votes) : Cleon, Violent Demise
Pool Entry (5 votes) : Galaxy, JazMerkin, Killersheep (+1), markb018
Nothing (0 votes) : N/A
David Tua enters the pool after his decision victory over Friday Ahunanya, by a vote of 5-2-0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
In a nasty, dirty 12 round match Hopkins came out on top. This is Jones 2nd loss in a row. Do we drop Jones ( currently #9 ), one spot to #10, to the pool, or to unranked status?
How far does Jones drop after his loss to Hopkins?
1 place to 10th (0 votes) : N/A
To pool (4 votes) : Galaxy, JazMerkin, markb018 (+1)
To unranked (3 votes) : Killersheep, TigerFan, Violent Demise
Jones drops to the pool by a vote of 4-3-0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
Antonio Tarver - Boxer hasn't won since 4/12/08, hasn't fought since 5/09/09 and seems to have moved on to a new career as an announcer.
Adrian Diaconu - Boxer hasn't won at Light Heavyweight since 4/19/08, he has fought as recently as 12/11/09.
Neither fighter has anything new scheduled. Should we give them a six month extension? Or should we drop them to the pool on the following dates:
Tarver at 4/12/10 and Diaconu at 4/19/10
Should Tarver and Diaconu get extensions after having over 2 years since winning?
Grant extension to Tarver, Grant extension to Diaconu
(0 votes) : N/A
Grant extenstion to Tarver, drop Diaconu to pool
(0 votes) : N/A
Drop Tarver to pool, grant extension to Diaconu
(2 votes) : JazMerkin, TigerFan
Drop Tarver to pool, drop Diaconu to pool
(5 votes) : Cleon, Galaxy, Killersheep, markb018 (+1)
Tarver and Diaconu are denied extensions by a vote of 5-2-0-0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
There is a huge vacuum effect going on at 175 largely cause by inactivity of the top fighters.
We have three pool members that have won their last fight and therefore qualify for the spot.
Nathan Cleverly - Boxer - last win on 2/13/10, a 5th round stoppage over Antonio Brancalion, no new fight booked
Karo Murat - Boxer - last win on 1/30/10, a 2nd round stoppage over Sean Corbin, he has a fight booked on 5/1/10 against a yet unnamed opponent.
Chris Henry - Boxer - last win on 3/27/10 against former Saddoboxing rated Hugo Hernan Garay, by means of 1st round stoppage, no fights booked.
Henry's blowout of Garay, coupled with his victory over George make it an easy choice for me!
Who fills the #8 spot at 175?
Nathan Cleverly (0 votes) : N/A
Karo Murat (0 votes) : N/A
Chris Henry (8 votes) : Cleon, Galaxy, JazMerkin, Killersheep, markb018 (+1), TigerFan, Violent Demise
Leave it Vacant (0 votes) : N/A
Chris Henry fills the #8 spot by a vote of 8-0-0-0
http://i5.photobucket.com/albums/y18...eavyweight.jpg
This probably look familiar as we just filled the #8 spot last week, who fills in #9?
Nathan Cleverly - Boxer
Karo Murat - Boxer
or should we leave it vacant?
I like Cleverly & I could just as easily choose him but I think Murat/ Karpency is the qualifier for me