Top 25 Pound-For-Pound List

Quote:

Originally Posted by LuciferTheGreat

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bomp

Can't criticise a list where the guy admits he's using his opinion. CC north.
IMO I'd put Calzaghe higher (cause I'm a fan) at the expense of putting Diego Corrales and Castillo lower down, possibly below Hatton as well on achievement. The only real big fight Castillo has won is his second with Corrales, in which he had a clear weight advantage.

Agreed with pulling Floyd down a peg or two, he probably is the most naturally gifted boxer, but he needs to prove it against either Hatton or Margarito. If he fights Vargas or Mosely it's a blatant cop out, he's been given the benefit of the doubt so far but shouldn't any longer, and should drop down even lower in the rankings. If there was no one else to fight on and around his weight division it would be ok to fo on this tour of has-beens, but that is not the case.

I agree mosley has seen better days and at 34 or 35 he won't improve so a fight with PBF really doesn't justify PBF's plan of only mega-fights from now on. Unless he just wants a passing of the guard thing.

I actually disagree... I think theres a damn good chance that Mosley would beat Hatton or Margarito, and would be a tougher fight for Floyd.. Don't really see it as a cop out to fight him at all, if he beats Vargas.. Plus im sure that would increase the chances and glamour DLH would get out of the fight with Mayweather.. I just can't hate on Floyd if that's what he does, I think anyone would if they were in his shoes. Plus anyone who has Floyd at number FOUR, is a little bit biased.. Who did he have in front?? Winky, Manny Pac... and who?? ::**