Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by Preme
1# Roy Jones Jr
2# Barrera
3# Mayweather
4# Mosely
5# De la hoya
6# Calzaghe
7# WInky
8# Ike Quertey
9# James toney
10# Tito
My list is mostley down to the boxers skills as i see them rather than who the boxer beat or what he won... although some are ranked lower than due to the fact they really havn't been able to prove what they can do...
Calzaghe above Winky,Quartey,Toney and Tito give me a can of what your drinking and to think i cool clicked you yesterday
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by tysonbruno
Quote:
Originally Posted by Preme
1# Roy Jones Jr
2# Barrera
3# Mayweather
4# Mosely
5# De la hoya
6# Calzaghe
7# WInky
8# Ike Quertey
9# James toney
10# Tito
My list is mostley down to the boxers skills as i see them rather than who the boxer beat or what he won... although some are ranked lower than due to the fact they really havn't been able to prove what they can do...
Calzaghe above Winky,Quartey,Toney and Tito give me a can of what your drinking and to think i cool clicked you yesterday
yea i disagree with that list too, mab is #2 ??? and no pacman ??? pac whoop him when pac wasn't even primed. Ike #8 ??? and no bhop ??? when i saw calzaghe above winky i figured it must of been his favorite list of fighters no so much p4p greats. but its ok its all of our oppinion.
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Ricardo Lopez should be top 10 p4p, and as much as I think hes overrated RJJ should take the #1 spot.
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by dgreen626
Roy Jones Jr.
Bhop
PBF
Trinidad
Winky
Pacman
Oscar
MAB
Morales
JMM
Shane
Heres :coolclick: #1 on me and welcome aboard, enjoy! your stay here at Casa De Saddos.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Taeth
I don't see how any here put Pacquaio so far up... He hasn't even been p4p champ yet, and doesn't even deserve #2 in his prime right now.
Completely agree on this, I like Pac but there is NO WAY he comes above some of the people you guys are rating him above of.
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by BoomBoom
Ricardo Lopez should be top 10 p4p, and as much as I think hes overrated RJJ should take the #1 spot.
Spot on BoomBoom can't believe Lopez was left out by everyone a man who RJJ himself said Lopez was P4P #1 at one point and not him (RJJ)
But I wouldn't rate him above RJJ.
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
1 PBF
2 Roy Jones Jr
3 Hopkins
4 Winky
5 ODLH
6 Mosely
7 Pacman
8 Barrera
9 Tony
10 Tito
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
1. MAB
2. RJJ
3. Tito
4. "Finito" Lopez
5. BHop
6. PBF
7. Pac
8. Winky
9. DLH
10. Mosley
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
OK... Here goes.
1. RJJ
2. Lopez
3. Hopkins
4. Toney
5. Winky
6. ODLH
7. SSM
8. PBF
9. Erik
10. MAB
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by tysonbruno
Quote:
Originally Posted by Preme
1# Roy Jones Jr
2# Barrera
3# Mayweather
4# Mosely
5# De la hoya
6# Calzaghe
7# WInky
8# Ike Quertey
9# James toney
10# Tito
My list is mostley down to the boxers skills as i see them rather than who the boxer beat or what he won... although some are ranked lower than due to the fact they really havn't been able to prove what they can do...
Calzaghe above Winky,Quartey,Toney and Tito give me a can of what your drinking and to think i cool clicked you yesterday
yo T-bruno, you should atleast make an attempt at doing a list before you bag someone elses :-X
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
ill have a crack ;)
roy jones
PBF
pac-man
MAB
ODLH
tito
holyfield
toney
eric morrales (spelling) ???
winky ??? couldnt think of anyone else ;)
i think all those guys deserve top 10 status, the order might be a bit whack! i just put winky cause couldnt think of anyone, im not certain he has done enough to deserve top 10 p4p
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
ohh i forgot about mosley. so fuk winky off my list and shane can take his spot at no#10 ;)
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
OK... Here goes.
1. RJJ
2. Lopez
3. Hopkins
4. Toney
5. Winky
6. ODLH
7. SSM
8. PBF
9. Erik
10. MAB
Order doesn't matter. We all seem to be going around the same names.
I agree. Somehow we should give honorable mention to the Pac, JL Castillo and L. Lewis (if he is in this generation--he wasn't 'protected', he beat everyone he ever faced, and is technically still the Ring Champ!)
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArawakWarria
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
OK... Here goes.
1. RJJ
2. Lopez
3. Hopkins
4. Toney
5. Winky
6. ODLH
7. SSM
8. PBF
9. Erik
10. MAB
Order doesn't matter. We all seem to be going around the same names.
I agree. Somehow we should give honorable mention to the Pac, JL Castillo and L. Lewis (if he is in this generation--he wasn't 'protected', he beat everyone he ever faced, and is technically still the Ring Champ!)
Heres CC#14, cause I agree on the honorable mentions.
Would also include Holyfield, Tito, JMM.
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
Quote:
Originally Posted by ArawakWarria
Quote:
Originally Posted by CutMeMicK
OK... Here goes.
1. RJJ
2. Lopez
3. Hopkins
4. Toney
5. Winky
6. ODLH
7. SSM
8. PBF
9. Erik
10. MAB
Order doesn't matter. We all seem to be going around the same names.
I agree. Somehow we should give honorable mention to the Pac, JL Castillo and L. Lewis (if he is in this generation--he wasn't 'protected', he beat everyone he ever faced, and is technically still the Ring Champ!)
Heres CC#14, cause I agree on the honorable mentions.
Would also include Holyfield, Tito, JMM.
CC--for me :-[ :-[ :-[??? Gee, thanks!
I thought long and I can only agree with JMM. The others are great fighters, but most of Holyfield's draws and losses came in this generation. I just can't bring myself to say that Tito was an all time great. Maybe I need to see more fights... O0
Re: Prime for prime, Pound for pound of this Generation
Quote:
Originally Posted by tysonbruno
Quote:
Originally Posted by Preme
1# Roy Jones Jr
2# Barrera
3# Mayweather
4# Mosely
5# De la hoya
6# Calzaghe
7# WInky
8# Ike Quertey
9# James toney
10# Tito
My list is mostley down to the boxers skills as i see them rather than who the boxer beat or what he won... although some are ranked lower than due to the fact they really havn't been able to prove what they can do...
Calzaghe above Winky,Quartey,Toney and Tito give me a can of what your drinking and to think i cool clicked you yesterday
Have a can of reality then ;)
Im guessing the comment means that you disagree on toney and tito bieng included...
And by this i can ceerrrtainly tell that you havnt seen enough of toney in his prime..
Before he lost interest and discipline..The guy was a bigger P4P star then floyd by far..
His skills are/were crazy..He was fighting the best,beating them..He had wicked power a middle and supermiddle..Just a complete package...
And tito speaks for himself..He took the best fights in a great era.. And finished off great opposition in style..
Say what you want about don king..But tito wanted to fight the best and king delivered huge fights!
