A P4P List With A Twist.

I am saying this whole idea is wrong, Marquez hasn't done enough to be #1, he didn't win the second fight against Pacquaio, he deserves the #2 or #3 spot.

Calzaghe regardless of whether he beat Hopkins or not fought a really clsoe fight with Hopkins and beat Kessler, he should be in the top 5 no doubt. WTF is Mijares doing int he top 10 p4p yet? Especially at #5 thats very wrong, and don't even get me started on where you placed Pacquaio, if Marquez did beat in eitehr of those fights which he didn't, it would be by a point at most? That means Pacquaio should be in the top 3 by your logic.

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by Taeth

Quote:

---

Originally Posted by ICB

Ok i want you to do top 10 P4P list but say like you thought Marquez beat Pacquiao or etc, then i want you to put Marquez above Pacquiao or etc.

1 Juan Manuel Marquez
2 Bernard Hopkins
3 Israel Vasquez
4 Rafael Marquez
5 Christian Mijares
6 Manny Pacquiao
7 Antonio Margarito
8 Kelly Pavlik
9 Ivan Calderon
10 Joe Calzaghe

Ok few things here one i thought Marquez beat Pacquiao twice hence why he is P4P number 1, and thats why Pacquiao has been dropped down few places. I thought Hopkins went 1-1 with Taylor and i thought he beat Calzaghe hence why he is P4P number 2, i thought R.Marquez drawed with Vasquez hence why he is only one place below Vasquez, I thought Ivan Calderon lost to Cazares first time around hence why he is a few places lower, And i thought Calzaghe lost to Reid and Hopkins, hence why he is lower also. And i thought Margarito beat Santos so thats why i got him higher than Pavlik.

---

This is dumb, and your wrong on manyof the fights. Except the Hopkins part.

---

The only thing i dislike about you Taeth is that you think your opinion is right all the time even though you do know your boxing, you say theres no way Marquez won 2nd Pacquiao fight. But majority of boxing websites and boxing ringside reporters had Marquez winning and more boxing fans had Marquez winning aswell. So does that mean all there opinions aswell as mine are wrong because you think theres no way Marquez won ?

Christian Mijares beat a very good fighter in his last fight that was considered an even fight before, plus he has made many title defenses i think he deserves to be high in P4P rankings. I already explained why Calzaghe is lower because i think he lost to Robin Reid, aswell as Hopkins and if i think he lost to Reid that takes away one of his big achievements which is 20+ title defenses.