Re: Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?
The Poll has now closed. The results are as follows:
Hernan Marquez enters the #9 position by a vote of 3 points to 2
Re: Who fills the #10 spot at Strawweight?
The Poll has now closed. The results are as follows:
Manuel Vargas enters the #10 position by a vote of 4 points to 0
Should Dimitri Kirilov be removed from 115 Ratings?
Should Dimitri Kirilov (currently #7 at 115) be removed from Jr. Bantamweight Ratings to the pool? He has not fought Aug 2 '08 which was the KO loss to Darchinyan...
I vote yes
Re: Should Dimitri Kirilov be removed from 115 Ratings?
I'm with Galaxy on this one. Drop him to the pool.
Who fills the vacant #9 spot at Jr. Bantam?
With Dimitri Kirilov due to come out, we now have 2 vacant spots at 115. We had originally voted for Lopez/ Sonosona to be for the vacant #10 position but with Nonito Donaire moving up I think we should vote again to see who fills the vacant #8 spot:
Nonito Donaire/ Rafael Concepcion winner Aug 15
Jose Lopez/ Marvin Sonosona winner Sep 4
Roberto Vasquez/ Drian Francisco Oct 3
Re: Who fills the vacant #9 spot at Jr. Bantam?
The Concepcion-Donaire fight should fill one vacany and the Lopez-Sonosona should fill the other one
Re: Who fills the vacant #9 spot at Jr. Bantam?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Violent Demise
The Concepcion-Donaire fight should fill one vacany and the Lopez-Sonosona should fill the other one
That was my thinking, I voted for Donaire/ Concepcion for 9th, Lopez/ Sonosona is perfect for 10th, although I want my boy Vasquez back in the ratings again...
Re: Should Dimitri Kirilov be removed from 115 Ratings?
Re: Who fills the vacant #9 spot at Jr. Bantam?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Galaxy
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Violent Demise
The Concepcion-Donaire fight should fill one vacany and the Lopez-Sonosona should fill the other one
That was my thinking, I voted for Donaire/ Concepcion for 9th, Lopez/ Sonosona is perfect for 10th, although I want my boy Vasquez back in the ratings again...
I like Vazquez as well. But his opponent is the weakest of all by far
Re: Should Dimitri Kirilov be removed from 115 Ratings?
This poll has now closed. The results are as follows:
Dimitri Kirilov exits the ratings to the pool with a vote of 5 points to 0
Re: Who fills the vacant #9 spot at Jr. Bantam?
This poll is now closed. The results are as follows:
The winner of Nonito Donaire/ Rafael Concepcion on August 15 will fill the vacant #9 spot on a vote of 4 points to 2 points for Jose Lopez/ Marvin Sonosona winner & 1 point to leave to position vacant
Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?
We made a mistake in voting in Hernan Marquez into the vacant spot previously, when he was supposed to be for the pool at 115. So once again could we please have your votes on who should fill the vacant #9 position at 108:
Juanito Rubillar
Munetsugu Kayo
Adrian Hernandez
Brahim Asloum
Edren Dapudong
Rodel Mayol
My vote once again is for Mayol
Re: Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?
I refuse to rank someone of the basis of a draw so that leaves out Mayol (who hasn't had a meaningful win in three years by the way) and Kayo who hasn't had a win yet this year.
Adrian Hernandez, hasn't fought someone worth putting him into the pool and has been flirting with flyweight.
Brahim Asloum had a good victory over humberto pool, but that was at flyweight and was his first fight since 2007.
Edren Dadupong had a good win over Bert Batawang, but if Batawang would have won, I certainly wouldn't have ranked him based on the victory.
Rubillar is a pretty safe bet to say he's done.
Based on this I vote for Dapudong, also based on this I will be voting to leave the number 10 spot vacant in the future, fighters need to earn these ranks.
Re: Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?
I was well aware Marquez was bypassing the pool and into the rankings. There was no mistake. That was the intention. I didn't know it wasn't allowed. So be it. I say leave it vacant
Re: Who fills the #9 spot at Jr. Flyweight?
Quote:
Originally Posted by
killersheep
I refuse to rank someone of the basis of a draw so that leaves out Mayol (who hasn't had a meaningful win in three years by the way) and Kayo who hasn't had a win yet this year.
For me its more the fact that he didn't lose to our #1 guy, but I see where your coming from. The rematch looks set... unfortunately Calderon's gonna school him!
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Violent Demise
I was well aware Marquez was bypassing the pool and into the rankings. There was no mistake. That was the intention. I didn't know it wasn't allowed. So be it. I say leave it vacant
It is allowed for a fighter to bypass the pool, but Marquez has never fought at 108. The Esquer fight was at 115. We have moved him into the pool at 115. The mistake was voting on a guy who had never fought at that weight...
